M J Bridge
♦
♠
♥
♣
Responder root page
Bidding
This page last revised 5th Jan 2021
Post-
Both majors
Your basic approach to making a change of suit response will be that given under ‘the traditional approach’.
This includes the guidance to bid five-
♠
♥
♦
♣
A K 6 4 2
Q J 8 5
7 4
T 8
|
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
You |
|
|
1♦ |
- |
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Suppose you respond 1♠ on this hand.
If partner rebids 2♦ then you can make a natural bid of 2♥ -
If partner rebids 1NT then 2♥ will not be forcing, but it keeps the bidding open and partner will surely raise to three with his fifteen points if holding four hearts. Of course, this possibility will not arise if like me you open the major when holding four cards in each of a major and a minor.
If partner rebids 2♣ then 2♥ by you would be fourth suit forcing -
With twelve or so points this would be the correct action, but in the present situation you can do no better than 2NT. If partner happens to hold fifteen or so points he can bid 3♥ on his way to game, but this would not usually be played as promising four hearts.
There is no way to finish in a heart contract in this auction.
However, bear in mind that this will be an extremely rare situation -
All in all the traditional guideline to respond in spades first is perfectly adequate in the present context.
I have introduced a concern which in this particular case has little or no substance.
When partner opens one of a minor and you hold both majors and a hand of invitational strength or better stick with the traditional guidelines -
Intermediate and above
Recommended is that you stick with this traditional guidance in the present context.
There might be some concern that in some sequences you may never get to show your second suit in a natural manner and that a suit fit might therefore be missed.
The situation has already been addressed in the context of a minimum responding hand (see only one bid) and in that scenario there is certainly an argument for deviating from the standard method. That consideration will apply to non-
I have also discussed those situations in which you hold a five-
In the present context the concern should only arise when you hold five spades and four or five hearts, together with invitational values or better.
Context -
| Opener |
| Overcaller |
| Responder |
| Advancer |
| Opener's rebid |
| Overcaller's rebid and beyond |
| Responder's rebid and beyond |
| The continuing auction |