M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Opener’s first bid

This page last revised 4th Apr 2024

Opener’s rebid

Post-beginner and above

Minor or major?


Your basic approach to making a change of suit response will be that given under ‘the traditional approach’.

This includes the guidance that, given that you hold sufficient strength, you should bid five-card suits before four-card suits, the higher-ranking of two five-card suits, and four-card suits 'up the line'.

You could do worse than stick rigidly to this guidance which will correspond to much club play and will see you through to quite a high level.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 8 5

T 8

K 4

A K 6 4 2

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

?









Intermediate and above

There might, though, be some concern that in some sequences you may never get to show your four-card major when this is your natural second bid.

The matter is directly related to the strength of your hand, and how forcing you have agreed that certain sequences should be.


First of all, there will not be a difficulty if you hold game-going values.


There will be ample bidding space in which to show the full nature of your hand in accordance with the traditional guidelines.

On this hand you will start with 2♣ - your five-card suit.

If partner rebids 2♦ then 2♠ will be a responder's reverse, natural and forcing for at least one round (but see 'invitational values' below);

if partner rebids 2♥ it will be a reverse and game-forcing facing your two-level response;

if partner rebids 2♠ it will again be a game-forcing reverse and you can choose your route to at least 4♠;

if partner rebids 2NT it will again be game-forcing, and 3♠ by you will be natural and forcing.

Only if partner raises to 3♣ will you have anything of a problem. 3♠ by you at this point will certainly be forcing but might show no more than a no trump stop or a control. However, for partner to hold four spades he would have to have a 4-0-5-4 shape with less than reversing values (or he would have preferred 2♠). Unlikely, but if he cannot support spades or bid no trumps then he can always revert to clubs which may well turn out to be the optimum strain.


The situation is not dissimilar if partner opens 1♣ and you hold four or five diamonds and a four-card major.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 8 5

T 8

A K 6 4 2

K 7

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

?









Bid 1♦.

If partner rebids 1♥ then a rebid of 1♠ by you becomes the fourth suit.

Modern style, and recommended, is to play the bid of ‘the fourth suit at the one-level’ as natural and forcing for one round.

If partner rebids 1♠ then you can choose your route to 4♠.

If partner rebids 1NT or 2♣ then 2♠ by you will be a responder's reverse - forcing for at least one round according to the partnership agreement

And if partner raises your diamonds then he should not hold four spades but 2♠ from you will be forcing and you should find your way to either 3NT or 5♦.


There is though a potential difficulty when holding just invitational values.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 8 5

T 8

K 4

A J 6 4 2

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

?









If you make a first response of 2♣ and partner makes a game-forcing rebid (see above) then you can continue as above.


However, if partner makes a limited response of 1NT or 2♦ then there is a further consideration.

A bid of 2♥ or 2♠ by you at this point would be a responder's reverse.

This is a situation in which modern expert practice has changed.

Traditionally such a bid would have been a one-round force and the auction could still die in 2NT or three of a suit.

If you play such a bid in this way then an initial response of 2♣ followed by a rebid of 2♠ would be correct on the hand above, showing your shape accurately and quite possibly leading to a final contract of 2NT which would reflect your invitational values.

Modern expert practice, though, is to play the responder's reverse as game-forcing

This has immediate advantages if your main priority in bidding is to locate the optimum game and slam contracts, as will be the case if you play much of your bridge in matches or tournaments with imp or cross-imps scoring.

The downside is that you might lose a little accuracy in the bidding of part-score contracts.


Note that the recommendation which follows differs in detail from that on an earlier version of this page.


So, if you play much of your bridge at imp or cross-imp scoring it is recommended that you adopt the newer game-forcing style of a responder's reverse.


If you make this choice then there is much to be said for a first response of 1♠ on invitational hands such as the one above to ensure that any possible major suit fit is not missed. Partner's non-fit response of 2NT would then be non-forcing and may well turn out to be the best contract.


Not every expert will agree with me on the following, but


if most of your bridge is played at match-pointed pairs, typically in a club environment, in which an accurate part-score can score a 'top on the board' just as easily as a well-judged game or slam, then you might find that the traditional approach starting with 2♣ and following with a 1♠ one-round force will serve you just as well.


In some cases it might also contribute to the possibility of happy partners.


The situation is different again when holding minimal responding values.

♠

♥

♦

♣

T 8

J T 8 5

A 9 6 4 2

7 4

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

?










This paragraph refers to hands of about 5 to 7 points.

I categorize them as hands worth just one bid.

You might show a simple natural preference to partner's first suit on your rebid, or you might repeat your own six-card suit depending on the partnership agreement on the strength shown by such a bid, but otherwise you will have no more to say.

On the hand above you will make a first response of 1♦, but other than a simple preference from 1♠ to 2♣ you will have no more to say..

You will find more on this topic on the page ‘only one bid’.


Eight or nine points.


These are the hands which do not warrant a rebid promising invitational values, but on which you should strive to keep the bidding open just in case partner holds 17 or 18 points.

The options available are a rebid of 1NT, a rebid of your own six-card suit, or a 'false preference' to partner's first suit.

You may agree to promise a minimum of eight points with the first two of these options, but not with the third for the simple reason that the preference won't always be 'false'.

♠

♥

♦

♣

T 8 6

J T 8 5

A 9 4 2

K 4

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

?









On this hand you would make an initial response of 1♦, planning to rebid 1NT if partner were to rebid 1♠.



It goes without saying that your agreements should be consistent with those when partner opens one of a major .

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s first bid - partner opened one minor in first or second seat - no intervention - moving forwards - change of suit at the lowest level.