M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Opener’s first bid

Only one bid


The assumption on this page is that partner opened one of a minor and that you are planning to change suit at the one-level.


The traditional guidelines were outlined on the page the traditional approach - by all means stick with them.


However, these traditional guidelines were formulated as a means of showing the shape of your hand in two bids.

Hardly surprisingly, they might not lead to the best outcome when the hand warrants only one bid.


The following hand turned up in a recent club multiple teams event.

Post-beginner and above


It goes almost without saying that partner opened with 1♣ - some partners are like that.

Responder dutifully bid 1♥ in accordance with the ‘traditional guidelines’ and predictably, opener rebid 2♣ - and there the auction ended.


You have surely guessed - opener had started with five clubs, four diamonds, and thirteen points.

The club contract duly made 6 tricks.

Diamonds would have made ten tricks, spades made 8 tricks on a 4-3 fit, and hearts even made 8 tricks on a 5-1 fit!

2♣ was the worst contract.


Fortunately, we were the defending side and we were very happy to walk away with a pleasant little 6 imp swing.


So what went wrong?


Responder should have realised that five clubs and four diamonds was quite a likely holding for opener, with this inevitable outcome. Indeed, if responder’s spades and hearts had been reversed then a 1♠ response would risk missing the best contract whenever opener held five clubs together with either four diamonds or four hearts.

On the present hand 1♦ is by far the best response.  If by any chance opener then rebids his clubs you can at least be assured of a six-card fit, whilst all the other denominations remain available.


Every hand must be judged on its individual merits, but on any hand which is worth only one bid in the first instance (in general not ten points, nor eight or nine with a six-card suit of your own) and with less than two-card support for partner, it will always be worth at least considering a response in the cheapest suit you can stand as a means of keeping opener’s options open.

This page last revised 2nd Jan 2021

Opener’s rebid

♠

♥

♦

♣

K 8 3 2

K J 5 4 2

T 5 4 3

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q 9 5 2

J 9 8 6 2

T

7 4

The traditional bid would be 1♠ - and it’s not wrong - but what are you planning to do after 1♦, 1♠, 2♣ -

are you really going to bid 2♥ (fourth suit - probably played as game-forcing),

and even after - 1♦, 1♠, 2♦ - 2♥ is usually played as third suit forcing.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

?










There is much to be said for a first response of 1♥, on this hand just in case opener holds five diamonds, four (or even three) hearts, and about thirteen points.


Note that whatever you do things can still take a nasty turn.

Life is a whole lot more comfortable if the minor suit holdings are interchanged thereby allowing you to more easily return to diamonds.

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s first bid - partner opened one minor in first or second seat - no intervention - moving forwards - change of suit at the lowest level.