M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

 Responder root page

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Major or minor?


Note that the suggestions which follow differ significantly from those given on earlier versions of this page.


The basic approach to making a change of suit response will be that given under ‘the traditional approach’.


This includes the guidance to bid five-card suits before four-card suits (strength permitting).


That will be the most common practice in club play.

Intermediate and above

This page focuses on the situation in which you have a choice of bidding a four-card major at the one-level or a five-card minor at the two-level. In the present context the decision will arise only when partner opens 1♥ and you hold four spades and five of a minor together with sufficient strength to make a change of suit at the two-level - typically 9+ points.


You could do far worse than to stick with the traditional approach of starting with the five-card minor in all situations, particularly if you play most of your bridge at match-pointed pairs (most club play) in which the correct part-score can be as important as finding the best game or slam.


The choice is inextricably linked to your partnership agreements regarding a responder's reverse or a bid in the fourth suit on responder's rebid. Traditionally the responder's reverse was always played as a one-round force on invitational or better values whilst the bid in the fourth suit might have been played either as a one-round force or as game-forcing.

If both were played as one-round forces then when holding invitational or better values responder could always start by bidding the minor at the two-level followed by the major, safe in the knowledge that the auction could still stop at 2NT or three of a suit.

More recently a majority of top partnerships have moved to playing one or both of these conventions as game-forcing. This has immediate advantages if the primary aim is to locate the best game or slam, but in most continuations they leave you with no way of showing the four-card major if you start with the minor when holding only invitational values.


Beginner and above

Opener’s first bid

Opener’s rebid

This page last revised 24th Mar 2024

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s first bid - partner opened one major in first or second seat - no intervention - you have less than three-card support.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 8 5

T 8

7 4

A K 6 4 2

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♥

-

?










Responding 2♣ on the first hand above works perfectly well, and most would see this as the correct choice.


If partner rebids 2♠ (a natural and game-forcing reverse) all your problems will have disappeared, although you might now have a slam interest;

if partner rebids 2NT then your rebid of 3♠ will be natural and game-forcing;

if partner rebids 2♦ then you can again bid 2♠ fourth suit, forcing for at least one round according to the partnership agreement (provided that you are agreed that partner will raise spades if he holds four of them (a slightly improbable 4-5-4-0 shape)) then you will again be able to choose your game contract with your next bid;

and if partner rebids 2♥ then your bid of 2♠ will be a responder’s reverse which you are strong enough to deal with whether you play it as a one-round force or as game-forcing.


In the second example you hold just invitational values. (If a spade fit is located then you will revalue the hand as seven-loser and force to game.)


If you start with 2♣ and partner responds either 2♦ or 2♥, and you play your rebid of 2♠ as game-forcing, then you will never get to show your 4-card major.

In this situation a first response of 1♠ is recommended.



Bid 1♠.


If partner rebids 2♦ or 2♥ you will rebid 2NT, although there is the option of discussing the meaning of 3♣ at this point with your partner.

The shape isn't perfect for a no trump bid, but it shows the strength and is probably better than something suggesting a more shapely holding.

Partner can still bid a natural and forcing 3♠ if able to go on to game, but the occasional spade part-score might be missed.

It is in fact impossible to finish in a spade part-score in this sequence.  The saving grace is that it would require a fairly unlikely 4-5-4-0 distribution in partner’s hand.


If partner rebids 2NT you will again be able to bid a natural 3♠,


and if partner bids 3♥ you will have the choice of 3NT or 4♥.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 5

T 8

7 4

A 9 6 4 2

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♥

-

?









♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 5

T 8

7 4

A K 6 4 2

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♥

-

?










If you play much of your bridge at match-pointed pairs scoring in a club context then there is much to be said for sticking with the traditional approach of always starting with two of the minor provided that you are strong enough to change suit at the two-level, and combining this with a responder's reverse played as invitational or better and forcing for one round.



If on the other hand you play more of your bridge in a match-play scenario in which locating the correct game or slam is of paramount importance then it is probably better to agree with your partner to bid the minor first when holding game-going values but to start with one of the major when holding no more than invitational values, and combining this with a responder's reverse played as game-forcing.



In either case you should be sure to align your methods with your choices when partner opens one of a minor.