Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Teaching

Theory

Context  -  Acol bidding - the opening bid.

5-3-3-2 shape


5-3-3-2 hands are, by definition, balanced.


With a hand too strong to open 1NT and less than a 2NT opener there is only one way to bid such a hand.

You will open one of your five-card suit, and if a fit is not immediately forthcoming you will rebid some suitable number of no trumps (see the page fifteen to nineteen).

With sufficient strength for a game contract responder will show three-card support in the continuing auction and a superior 5-3 fit will not be lost.

Question

My guideline

When do I open 1NT on a balanced 12-14 point hand with a good five-card minor?

Always.


Five-card major


There is much to be said at the beginning stage for always opening 12 -14 balanced hands with 1NT, whether or not they contain a five-card major.

And it would not be silly to retain this method as you progress to higher levels.


Note that you will still be able to show your five-card major on many game-going hands following either a limit raise or a Stayman bid by partner.

This page last revised 7th Sep 2025

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q 5

8 7 5

A K Q 4 2

3 2

5-3-3-2 shape, 14 HCP, a strong five-card minor.

You have a choice between opening 1♦ then rebidding 2♦, and opening 1NT on this hand.

1NT is to be preferred to 1♦ - and don’t worry about the weak clubs and hearts - there will almost always be a weak suit or two in a 12-14 1NT opener.

Beginner and above

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K Q 4 2

Q 7 5

K Q 5

Q 2

5-3-3-2 shape, 18 HCP, and a strong five-card major.

Open 1♠ planning to rebid 2NT.

If partner is able to accept the invitation he will bid 3♠ on his way to 3NT when holding three-card support, which you will raise to 4♠.


Twelve to fourteen points


It is only within your agreed range for an opening bid of 1NT (usually 12 to 14) that you will need to agree your partnership method.


Five-card minor


When the five-card suit is minor there is near universal agreement as to the correct approach.


The preferred target contract will be 3NT more often than anything in a minor, particularly on a balanced hand.

All balanced hands containing a five-card minor should be opened 1NT if in the agreed range.


Indeed, it will be rare that an opening bid of one minor followed by a rebid in that suit will be made on anything less than a six-card suit.

However, as you proceed you will come across other methods and you might choose to follow one of them.


I shall offer you three options.


Option 1

Always open a five-card major if you have one, then rebid it at the two-level


If the hand contains a five-card major, it will be opened with one of that suit, followed by a rebid in the same suit, almost irrespective of any other feature of the hand.


It is a method still encountered in many clubs, where it is passed down from generation to generation.

It is certainly a playable option, but you will sometimes feel a little silly when you hold something like 65432.


In an unbalanced hand opening the five-card suit will almost always be correct, but priority should be given to rebidding in the four-card suit whenever possible - not rebidding in no trumps.


With a balanced hand containing a five-card major in the 12-14 point range if you choose to open with one of the major then you will have no choice other than to rebid that suit.

it is a reasonable option with a good suit, but it should not be an ‘always’ method.

Note that if you choose always to open this balanced hand containing a 5-card major with 1NT then the suit opening followed by a rebid of that suit is far more likely to promise a 6-card suit.

It has long since been realised that the need for opener to rebid that five-card suit at the earliest possible opportunity is not nearly as pressing as was once thought. Instead the onus moves to responder to show three-card support in the ongoing auction.


Option 2

Always open 1NT


Note that this is the method long advocated by Andrew Robson.

It has also more recently (October 2019) been adopted as the preferred teaching method by EBED - the teaching branch of the ebu.


This is my recommended method at both beginner and improver levels, and if you stick with it beyond that you won't go far wrong.

Option 3

Mix and match


The obvious compromise is to vary the opening bid according to the specific holding, but the question arises as to which specific holdings lead to each choice.


A typical choice would be to open one of the major with a good suit (two top honours or three out of five honours would be a minimum requirement) but to open 1NT otherwise.


Which method?


As stated above Andrew Robson and EBED advocate always opening 1NT with these hands.


By way of contrast, Jeffrey Allerton and Chris Jagger ‘open the suit more often than 1NT, and when they do open 1NT it will depend more on the look of the whole hand rather than simply the quality of the major suit’.


My thoughts


I can’t for one moment think of a single good reason why you might want to consider my thoughts on the matter rather than those of the illustrious experts mentioned above - basically you choose which expert you want to follow - clearly both options 2 and 3 can be successful at the highest levels.


But, for what it’s worth, here goes.


Note that the following thoughts are far less prescriptive than they were in earlier versions of this page.


If you do choose to mix and match then the considerations will probably revolve around both the quality of the suit and the form of the game - e.g. pairs or teams.


As regards suit quality my feeling is that to open the suit and then rebid it you should be happy with the possibility that you might be facing just 2-card support - something like AKQJx, or to put it another way - 'it looks like a 6-card suit'.


As regards the form of the game, it will sometimes be beneficial to play in a suit part-score when facing a particularly weak dummy at pairs. It avoids the possibility of the opponents running through you in the other three suits before you get started.


Conversely, at teams scoring it is the game and slam bonuses (along with doubled and vulnerable penalties) that are all important. The occasional disaster in a low-level part-score is of relatively minor significance.

With this thought in mind it can be invaluable for partner to know that the hand is balanced. The possibility of a singleton or void in a potential slam contract is a significant consideration.


I tend towards the ‘always open 1NT’ approach, but I might just be swayed towards opening one of 'what looks like a 6-card major suit', particularly at pairs scoring.


So, there is no clear-cut 'best' approach. Just agree your approach as a partnership - and be certain that you are both making the same assumptions.

Post-beginner and above

Question

Answer

My guideline

Can I open 1NT on a 12-14 point hand containing a five-card major?

Yes, if it has 5-3-3-2 shape.

It is a matter of partnership agreement whether you open one of the suit or 1NT when holding a good five-card major.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 6 5 2

7 3

J T 4

K Q 3

5-3-3-2 shape and 13 HCP.

I open 1♠ on this hand at either form of scoring.

Other agreements are perfectly acceptable.