Why Acol
A majority of club partnerships and casual players in the UK play a system which is essentially natural with a weak no trump and four-card majors - i.e. Acol, or something very similar. My understanding is that this is also the case in a few other countries, most likely members or past members of the British commonwealth.
Elsewhere the picture is very different. Throughout the world as a whole a majority of partnerships play a system which is essentially natural based around a strong no trump and (usually) five-card majors - typically although not necessarily SAYC (Standard American Yellow Card).
This pattern is hardly surprising and has developed for historical reasons. To be honest, give or take a little matter of legality, it’s not all that different from which side of the road you learned to drive on. It says little about the relative merits of the two approaches.
However, a different picture emerges when we look at the partnerships which dominate in serious competition whether international or national, and including the UK.
Almost without exception they will play either a system which is basically natural with a strong no trump and five-card majors, or a system which is basically artificial usually with at least some similarities to the Precision system.
It is tempting to deduce that such a system must be superior in itself, but such a deduction is not sound:-
first of all, there can be little doubt that these top partnerships would remain top partnerships, such is their intelligence and card-sense, playing any well thought-out system;
secondly, it is hardly surprising that a majority of top players play a system based on a strong no trump, for the simple reason that they are drawn from a larger pool;
and as for those UK pairs which have chosen the strong no trump route some have simply followed what they have seen around them - others have chosen an approach which will allow them to partner other top players from around the world when they go searching for a partner (by which I mean a bridge partner) on-line or in person for serious competition.
The last consideration above is valid, but I will suggest that there are good reasons for learning and sticking with Acol. Clearly the following are personal views, but I am not alone in them.
1.
There is a strong argument for teaching a natural system (no short minors). It emphasises the importance of the shape of the hand, and the need to show that shape in the bidding. This can be a perception which is sadly missing amongst those who have started with a less natural method.
2.
There is no doubt in my mind that a natural method featuring a weak no trump is best for match-pointed pairs play. This is the form of the game played most frequently in club bridge.
The reason is because the form of scoring values each part-score hand equally with the game- and slam-going contracts. Accurate bidding in the part-score zone is just as important as getting the big hands right.
The natural opening bids of one of a suit along with the more frequent appearance of the preemptive 1NT opening mean that you will get the one-level and two-level contracts right more often and your opponents will get such contracts wrong more often.
3.
Further, the emphasis on locating a 4-4 major suit fit (rather than 5-3) will locate an extra trick for an excellent pairs score more often than it will fail due to a bad break.
But even playing for IMPS (International Match Points which value the big swings considerably more than 50 or 100 here and there) in serious top-class competition I am convinced that Acol can hold its own.
a) Most systems specify one opening bid at the one-level to be closely defined, and that bid will usually be 1NT.
Bids at the two-level and higher may or may not also be closely defined, but that leaves the other opening bids at the one-level to cover everything else.
A 12-14 point balanced hand is significantly more common than one in the 15-17 point range. You will therefore take the initiative more frequently, preempting your opponents to an extent and putting partner in control with a clear picture of your hand whilst at the same time relieving the pressure on those other bids thereby giving them greater definition.
Advocates of the strong no trump will reference the dangers of the weak no trump and the risk of going for a substantial and expensive penalty. At pairs scoring the occasional disaster of this nature is neither here nor there - so you had a bad board.
There is of course a risk involved but the dangers are overstated. In these days of ‘wriggles’ a loss of 300 in this situation is rare and a loss of 500 or 800 is even rarer. On those rare occasions when such losses do occur your opponents will almost always have a contract worth at least 400 available their way, and so even at teams scoring the dangers are greatly over-exaggerated. You should not be cowed by these arguments. It should also be remembered that the strong no-trumper encounters almost identical problems when having to rebid 1NT, and sometimes even 2NT on a twelve (or eleven) to fourteen-point hand - the assurance of six points opposite really doesn’t make that much difference.
b) The advantages of a five-card major system are also greatly over-hyped (in my humblish opinion).
Certainly we all feel far more comfortable in a 5-3 fit as the opponents’ trumps split 4-1, particularly if there is a ruffing trick to be made in the short suit, but against this the 4-4 fit will frequently create an extra trick against the more common 3-2 split as you choose in which hand to take your ruff, and if this happens to be the tenth trick in a game contract or the twelfth trick in a slam it will prove a significant preference (the situation is analysed in some depth in the theory section).
It is also worth noting then when you open one of a suit you promise to define your hand more precisely with your second bid - it will be rare that you cannot more or less promise five cards in your first suit at that point.
Furthermore any system based on five-card majors will usually have to open on a shorter suit in at least one of the minors. It will inevitably be more difficult to define the hand with any degree of accuracy on the second bid. You should take the opportunity to disrupt sequences based on such an opening bid whenever reasonable.
c) I know that exceptions don’t prove the rule, but it is significant that Jeffrey Allerton and Chris Jagger recently qualified to represent England in the Bermuda Bowl (Sept 2019) playing Acol - the system can certainly survive at this level.
Although I believe the weak no trump to be theoretically superior, it is a close call. The counter argument is at least worthy of consideration.
I certainly believe that Acol is the system to teach in the first instance - and I certainly believe that Acol is marginally superior when playing for match-pointed pairs.
I also believe that Acol is due for something of a revival at the highest levels of the game.
It needs to be said, though, that whichever system you choose it will only prove competitive at a high level if you have agreed the meaning of various sequences in extended and competitive auctions. This detail in extended sequences is far more important than the underlying decisions about no trumps and four-card majors.
Chris Jagger (see above) has recently (Oct 2019) started a series of articles in English Bridge outlining the methods and interpretations which he and Jeffrey have adopted.
I am currently working to incorporate some of their wisdom into this site.