Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Teaching

Openers rebid

root page

Theory

This page last updated 18th Oct 2021

Context  -  You opened 1NT - LHO passed - intermediate and beyond - partner bid Stayman - four-card promissory.


As stated above this method is not adopted by all expert partnerships.

Of rather more concern is that some experts argue strongly against it.  In particular, Sarah Bell in her Acolytes column in the June 2020 edition of English Bridge quotes the following hand

Responder’s first bid

Responder’s rebid

Slightly contentious

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 8 7

K Q 5 4 3

K J 6

K 2

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1NT

-

2♣

-

?









with the sentence ‘Don’t think about jumping to 3♥ to show five - the 3♥ bid doesn’t exist for a reason.’ contained in her comments.


Before I go any further let me be quite clear that Sarah’s claims to bridge expertise and insight are far in excess of mine.  It would be reasonable, not to say sensible, to choose to follow her guidance ahead of mine,


but I remain less than totally convinced by her argument.


Let me look at six possible hands which partner might hold for his bid.


Clearly this is not a random selection - I have constructed them for a purpose - but they pretty much cover the extremes and highlight the important considerations.


Hand A


This will finish in the correct contract of 3NT whichever route you choose.

It will make at least nine tricks depending on the lie of the ♠K unless the defence can set something up as you knock out three aces.


Hand B


This should finish in the correct contract of 4♥ either way, but if your first response is 2♥ then you must rebid 3♥ on the way to game over partner’s 2NT rebid to show your five-card holding.

There are good chances of ten tricks here, but you will be holding your breath over a finesse or two, and the possibility of a spade ruff following just two rounds of trumps.


Hand C


If you start with 2♥ then partner will rebid 3NT and that will be the final contract (unless partner prefers 4♥ on a possible 4-3 fit in light of his poor clubs).

If you start with 3♥ then you will finish in 4♥.

As in hand B 3NT should fail on a club lead even if the ace lies right.

4♥ is not quite cast-iron, but at least the odds are in its favour.


Hand D


I must admit, I quite like this one - it’s almost a double fit.

If we aren’t making a lot of tricks then the opponents are.

Even with just a doubleton spade in opener’s hand I would want to compete fairly vigorously at most vulnerabilities, and that would mean bidding to the three-level in hearts on the nine-card fit.


Hand E


If you bid 2♥ it is all but inconceivable that your opponents won’t enter the auction, and quite possibly make a game in clubs unless they decide to double you for penalties.  Of course, if you’re lucky they’ll go one too far, but don’t count on it.

If you bid 3♥ you will probably finish in 3♥x if your opponents’ methods allow that, and if not there is a possibility that they will finish in 4♣ when they have a game on.


The law of total tricks suggests that if the opponents can make eleven tricks on a ten-card fit then you can make eight tricks on your 9-card fit.

No promises, obviously, but two down even doubled is quite likely to score well except when vulnerable against not.  So even seven tricks in a three-level contract is likely to score well most of the time.


Hand F


This is the one you were afraid of with the jump response leaving you at the three-level on an 8-card fit and a combined 14 points.

This time, going by the law of total tricks, if the opponents can make eleven tricks then you will be restricted to seven.

Still a good score much of the time but decidedly more dangerous than hand E.


Evaluation


On hand A your method makes no difference.

This is also true of hand B, but be certain that you have the rebid of 3♥ in your repertoire if you started with 2♥ and partner rebid 2NT.


Hand C is critical.

The jump response will give you a game swing on occasion unless you have included some version of 5-card Stayman in your methods.


Hand D will usually be well worth the competition.


The first thing to say about hands E and F is that they are extreme - they won’t usually be as weak as this.

The second point to make is that they are rare.  4-4-4-1 for example is fairly uncommon even before you insist on the shortage being in clubs.


When they do happen you have the opportunity to cause considerable mayhem on a hand which belongs to the opponents, usually at little cost to yourself.


I suspect that standard expert practice evolved before the effectiveness of bidding to the level of the fit became so well known.


I certainly won’t blame you if you choose to listen to the acknowledged experts, but for me it makes sense -


either to incorporate a version of 5-card Stayman into your methods (that’s hand C dealt with

and/or to agree make this jump bid whenever you hold a five-card major in a maximum hand and you are not vulnerable.


Whether or not you wish to extend this method to ‘both sides vulnerable’ or ‘always’ is for you to decide,

but if your partnership agreement is to jump rapidly to the level of the fit in other situations (and yes - you will on occasion go one higher than you needed to) then it seems to me to be no more than ‘consistent’ to incorporate the bid into your methods.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 4 2

J 7

Q T 8 5

Q J 5

Hand A

♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 4 2

J 7 6

A 8 7 5

J T

Hand B

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 4 2

J 7 6

A 8 7 5

J T

Hand C

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 5 4 2

T 8 7 6

9 7 4 2

5

Hand E

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 5 4 2

8 6 2

T 9 7 5 4

5

Hand F

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 6 5 4 2

T 8 7 6

9 4 2

5

Hand D

Jump in a major


The main concern when opening 1NT with a five-card major is that you might never get to show this feature.

Here is one of two ways in which you can pass on this information in a game-going auction following the 1NT opening bid.  (The other is when partner makes a limit raise to 2NT, either directly or indirectly.)


Quite simply jump in your five-card major to show this feature (but see below).

Note that your hand is already limited by your choice of opening bid.


This method makes sense to me; I have come across it in good company (albeit only occasionally); and it is (by the way) part of the bidding system on a downloaded bridge game which I play at home;

but having said that it is far from universal and it is by no means adopted by all good and expert partnerships.


Such an action might feel dangerous at first, with a possibility that you might find yourself at the three-level holding only twelve points and facing a partner with absolutely nothing, but on further consideration you will realise that the risks are not as great as you might have first feared.


Partner will hold either at least invitational values with a planned rebid of 2NT/3NT or at least four cards in your major in a weak hand as part of a garbage Stayman sequence.  (The one possible exception is exemplified in hand F below.)


The more dangerous situation is in fact the one in which partner holds just invitational values.  If he also holds just two cards in your major then you risk putting him in an impossible situation.

The solution is easy - only make this bid when holding a maximum (fourteen points, or any holding on which you would always raise an invitational bid to game).

In this case the partnership will always have sufficient for game and partner will be well-placed to choose between 3NT and four of the major.


When partner has the weaker holding you will have made a rapid preemptive raise on a nine-card fit - usually good bridge.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 5 2

A 5 4

T 8 2

K 3

Bid 3♠.

If partner has eleven points, three spades and a weak suit this will be exactly what he wants to hear.  If his is a garbage sequence then 3♠ will be an excellent competitive contract more often than not.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1NT

-

2♣

-

?