Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Theory

Trial bids


The following is written in the context of the underlying approach to slam bidding discussed earlier.


A trial bid is a bid in a new suit following suit agreement.


Trial bids are unconditionally forcing for one round and force to at least the next level of the agreed suit.


Trial bids were discussed at some length in the section on conventions, and again at various points in the section on opener’s rebid.


Minor suits


Once a minor suit has been agreed any bid in a new suit below the level of 3NT will normally be played as a no trump stop.  Note that this is not the same as a control-showing cue-bid - QJx provides a stop but does not offer a first or second round control.


Occasionally the partner who introduced the new suit at the three-level will remove 3NT to the agreed minor.  Such a sequence is forcing below game-level, shows some sort of control in the side suit, and expresses at least an interest in a slam (unless there is a partnership agreement that the immediate bid at the four-level is a slam-try and that this slow route shows an invitational hand).


New suits following suit agreement at the four-level will be slam-tries - perhaps a control-showing cue-bid - but will frequently be part of some artificial method - possibly a key-card ask.


Major suits


Following major suit agreement any bid in a new suit will be some form of trial bid, and the suit will be assumed to have been set, although there are circumstances in which one member of the partnership might subsequently choose some alternative strain.


If the bidding has reached such a level that the auction can no longer stop in a part-score (e.g. a game-forcing auction has already been established or the auction has already reached too high a level) then it must be a slam-try trial bid.

Any form of slam-try trial bid will suggest that, from the perspective of the trial-suit bidder, there is still the possibility of a slam.

This is an important concept.  If you cannot see the possibility of a slam, based either on additional values in your own hand or the possibility of additional values in partner’s hand, then don’t make the trial bid - just bid the game.


The present page confines itself specifically to how trial bids may best be put to use in the context of a slam-try.


The term ‘trial bid’ is usually used to refer to the first bid in a new suit following suit agreement.

Subsequent bids are also likely to be slam-tries of one sort or another - usually some form of cue-bid - but it is the first trial bid with which I am presently concerned.


The trial bid will most usefully carry some further information, depending on the agreed style of trial bid in the context of the auction to date, to assist partner in coming to a decision.


Control-showing cue-bids are quite possibly the most common approach to slam-try trial bids in club play.  They provide an excellent first step towards a more all-embracing system of slam bidding., and in most situations are a considerable improvement on a headlong rush into Blackwood.

However, they are not the usual choice for the tournament player or expert as a first trial bid.


Sometimes the possibility of such a cue-bid will arise below the level of 3NT.  This will usually follow either a fourth suit bid, or game-forcing opening bid.

Recommended is a simple natural trial bid - typically at least a four-card second suit with at least some honours strength even if it’s only K J x x.  What could possibly help partner more in ascertaining whether or not the two hands work together to provide sufficient tricks?

Lacking such a suit just bid 3NT, denying such a side suit and inviting a cue-bidding sequence.


If the bidding has passed 3NT then this approach will be a little more difficult.

In principle it still makes sense, but you will certainly have to extend your definition of ‘natural’ to a decent three-card holding on occasion.


Other styles of trial bid are available to choose from.

There is much to be said for sticking with the natural approach as above for consistency.


There is, though, one specific circumstance which can arise in a number of different auctions when something different is strongly recommended.


Only one bid available


Whatever style of trial bid you might have agreed in general there is likely to be a problem when you have only one available bid with which to show the slam-try.

If a bid in that suit promises some feature which you do not hold then you will have to rely on Blackwood, or just take a punt at the slam.  Surprisingly frequently such an approach will work, but on other occasions it will take you one too far.


This situation is particularly likely to happen following a splinter bid.

In an auction such as 1♠, 4♦ (splinter agreeing spades) you have only 4♥ available to express a slam interest below the level of 4♠, and if your hand does not contain whatever feature is promised by your 4♥ trial bid then you cannot both show a slam interest and keep open the option of stopping in game.


The solution is simple - don’t promise anything with the trial bid other than to say that the hand is at least totally suitable for a slam-try if that is what partner wants to do.


I call such a bid a ‘How good are you?’ trial bid.  In some situations it is known as ‘last train’.


This style of trial bid is strongly recommended, whatever style you might have adopted in other sequences.

You may agree to extend it to the cheaper bid when you have two bids available.


Partner bid Jacoby or similar


Although the methods suggested in different contexts on this page will work perfectly well it is likely that you will have an agreed set of continuations specific to this convention.


Partner made a fit-jump


You already know a lot about your partner’s hand and whether or not the two hands work well together to provide a source of sufficient tricks.

This is the perfect setting for starting out on a cue-bidding sequence as you check for top losers in the other two suits.


Partner made a limit raise of your major to the three-level


As partner’s response is limited you should hold considerable extra potential before embarking on a slam-try.  Typically you will have nineteen or so points, and probably extra length in one or two suits.


You certainly won’t be alone in the world if you choose to embark immediately on a sequence of cue-bids as you investigate the possibility of a slam.

But, following the principle that you should ensure sufficient tricks before checking on controls and possible losers, there is much to be said for choosing ‘natural and shape-showing’ as above, suggesting a potential source of tricks.  ‘Long suit’ also has its supporters.


Following the trial bid partner will either sign off in the game contract or accept the invitation with your agreed style of cue-bid.


Partner made a Splinter raise


Bear in mind that a splinter bid will always promise a shortage in the bid suit and something like a seven-loser hand to justify the force to game-level, but the hand will frequently be lacking in the high-card values normally associated with a game-raise.


There are two distinct approaches in the expert world - it is important to agree on one of them.


i)  is that a splinter raise can cover quite a wide variety hands from light to a full-value opening bid or better.

If so you will probably agree a ‘How good are you?’ trial bid as indicated above, and insist on full-value when no trial bids are available.


ii)  increasingly popular in the expert world is the alternative that the splinter raise will always promise less than full opening values.

Stronger hands will travel by way of Jacoby or something of that nature.


If you follow the second route then make certain that responder has a way of showing his shortage in the ongoing auction.


It would be perverse of me not to recommend the second approach as it is the preferred method of many experts at the present time.

It does, though, seem to waste some of the potential of a splinter bid.

Beginner and above

Context  -  The continuing auction - in the slam zone.

This page last revised 7th Nov 2020