Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Teaching

Openers rebid

root page

Theory

Partner raised your suit to the two-level


This page assumes that RHO had the good manners to remain quiet.  If by any chance he came in with a lowest-level suit bid then the situation does not differ significantly from when LHO made a suit overcall which RHO then raised.  This situation is considered on its own page.


In the following I make two assumptions relating to partnership style.


The first is that when you open on a 4-4-4-1 hand you wil always make your opening bid in a minor suit - see opening 4-4-4-1 hands.


The second is that partner will raise your one of a major to the 2-level more than very occasionally on 3-card support.


Note that these two assumptions go hand in hand. You may, as a partnership, come to different agreements., but if you open 4-4-4-1 hands with one of a major and partner raises to the two-level on what might be no better than 3-card support then you will find yourself in real difficulties choosing your next bid whenever you hold extra strength.

With the assumptions above you will either have five (or more) cards in your major and be assured of at least an eight-card fit, or you will hold just four cards in the major in a balanced hand of 15 to 19 points.



Your major is four-card


Your hand will be balanced in the 15-19 point range.

Partner has limited himself to a maximum of 9 points.


With fifteen points

and a combined total of twenty four at best you will therefore pass.


It is a common beginner’s mistake to bid 2NT with this hand (as originally planned for a change of suit from partner), but now that partner has limited his hand there is no point in such action;

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A K

K T 9 8 6 5

9 4

J T 3

A perfectly respectable opener on eleven points and a six-card major, but that is all.

Your opponents are likely to have at least a part-score contract somewhere.

Bid 3♥ before they find it - this bid is not invitational in any way.

K T 9 8 6 5

9 4

J T 3

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








Trial Bids


The invitation will come in the form of a trial bid.

A trial bid is any lowest-level bid in a new suit following suit agreement.


It will be forcing, promising at least five cards in the major together with invitational values, and inviting partner to choose between three and four of the major.

Post-beginner and above

Responder’s first bid

Responder’s rebid

This page substantially rewritten 22nd Jan 2025

Context  -  Acol bidding - opener’s rebid - you opened one of a major in first or second seat - LHO passed -  partner supported your suit to the two-level.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K

K T 9 6 5

9 4

A T 9 3

6-loser hand, hence invitational.

Any one of 2♠, 3♣ or 3♦ will be a trial bid, forcing, promising five hearts, and inviting partner to choose between 3♥ and 4♥.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?









Bidding the game


With either nineteen points or a five-loser hand your usual action will be to jump to game in the major.

Once in a while you might jump to game pre-emptively on a seven-card suit and at least a ten-card fit.


♠

♥

♦

♣

A K J T 8 5 2

8 6 4

7

A 5

At least a ten-card fit.

Bid 4♠.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♠

-

2♠

-

?









Raise to the three-level


In earlier times this bid was always played as natural and invitational asking partner to either pass or raise to game.

Many club partnerships still play it in this way - there is a delightful straightforward simplicity to the method.


However, it wastes a valuable weapon as well as being far from the best way of consulting with partner (see invitational hands below).


You, as opener, might well have opened on an unbalanced hand with something like just ten points and a six-card suit.  When partner makes a six-point raise with no more than three-card support it will be time to keep the opponents out, and in my opinion there is no better use for a direct raise to the three-level than as a simple preemptive measure.

The principle of bidding rapidly to the level of the fit (the three-level on a nine-card fit in this case) is fundamental to much good bidding practice.


I might be at odds with some other teachers of the game in this matter but my feeling is that any regular partnership trying to build up a system together should adopt the pre-emptive interpretation for this bid and take all unbalanced invitational hands through a trial bid in a new suit (see below).

Invitational hands


The above does not address invitational hands - typically hands of seventeen or eighteen points or six-loser.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K T 8 5

K 8 6 4

K 7

A 5

Five losers.

Bid 4♠.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♠

2-

2♠

3-

?









Your assumption in making the bid will be that the final contract will be played in the major suit contract, but partner will have the option to redirect the auction to a no trump contract when holding 4-3-3-3 shape with little prospect of ruffing tricks in the shorter trump holding.


To help partner in his decision - particularly when he holds middle of the range values - the trial bid will usually tell him something else about your hand.


Style of trial bid


There is (?are - your choice) a plethora of different styles of trial bid from which to choose depending on what extra information you have agreed to give about your hand.

As a partnership you must agree which version you are going to play.


The three most commonly played versions in the present context are:-


natural and shape-showing;

long-suit;

and short-suit.


Any one of these basic methods may be further modified as indicated below.


Natural and shape-showing


In this version each of the possible trial bids will be forcing with at least five cards in the major and invitational values, but will carry the additional information that the bid suit is a potential source of tricks - typically at least four-card including two of the top three honours.

Of course, the exact requirements for such a bid may be varied by partnership agreement.


The high-card requirement is far from set in stone. Reasonable alternatives are '2 of the top 4', '3 of the top 4' or '3 of the top five'.

Another possibility is to stretch the length required to include 3-card suits provided that the high-card strength is well up to standard.

However, there is much to be said in insisting that a natural trial bid in the other major should guarantee at least a 4-card holding. With this agreement you will on occasion be able to finish up in a superior 4-4 fit. This applies in particular following the sequence 1♠ - 2♠ in which responder was not sufficiently strong to change suit at the two-level with 3 spades and four hearts.


The long-suit trial bid


With this style of trial bid you show a weakness rather than a strength.

Typically the bid suit will be at least 2-card, more often 3, and will contain at least 2 potential losers.

The hope is that partner might be able to nullify these losers with either a high honour holding or a shortage.

So, which one should you choose?


Well - it might not surprise you to hear that it's not quite that simple.


The short-suit trial bid was favoured by many in the early days of trial bids, but my impression is that it is not so common these days

(It seems to me that this method would make more sense if it showed a shortage in responder's hand with the potentially shorter trump holding and the possibility of gaining ruffing tricks in that hand. The same would apply to an extent if there were a guaranteed 4-4 fit between the two hands.);

the long-suit trial bid has long been a favourite and may well still be the front-runner;

and my impression is that the natural trial bid has a growing following. There is something to be said for the principle of bidding what you have got rather than what you haven't got.


Putting all other considerations aside my inclination is to prefer the natural style of trial bid, but it is far from a clear-cut decision.


But they all have the same underlying potential problem.

Whichever style you choose there will be some hands, well worth an invitation, which don't fit that style.

For that reason I must introduce a fourth style, and that is the simple


The 'how good are you?' trial bid.


This takes us back to the basic idea of stopping at a low level with a minimum and bidding the game with a maximum without offering any further information to aid that decision, other than that the hand does not qualify for your agreed alternative style of trial bid.


One example of such a bid is the simple natural and invitational raise to the 3-level discussed above, but with the added advantage that there are alternative routes available when the right hand comes along and that the use of this bid denies a holding suitable for any possible alternative.


An alternative option is to designate one of the other bids for this purpose.

Some authorities suggest the cheapest new suit for this purpose, but I prefer to keep the other major as a natural trial bid and so my choice for this bid is 3♣ over a minimum raise of either major.


This leaves me with the following structure:-


The immediate raise to three is natural and pre-emptive;

3♦ is a natural trial bid showing a good holding in diamonds;

a lowest-level bid in the other major is a natural trial bid showing a good holding of at least 4 cards in that suit;

3♣ is a general 'How good are you?' bid, promising invitational values and denying a suitable holding for any of the alternative trial bids.


I make no claim that this is the best allocation available, nor that it is the one favoured by any great number of stronger players, but it is the one I prefer and it will certainly serve you well to a high level.


Feel free to agree your own structure of bids in this situation. As long as it is one which you will both remember it will serve you well.


The commentary in the following examples uses my choice of allocation as given above, but you should feel free as a partnership to consider them in the light of your own agreed method.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 7 6

K Q 7 6

K 8 6

Q 3

Pass.

Fifteen points are not enough to justify a further try following partner’s limited response.  


with sixteen points

there is the possibility of a combined twenty five points.


But bear in mind that even if partner holds nine points they are not a particularly prepossessing nine points.  With just three-card support partner will not hold a decent five-card suit which would have justified a change of suit at the two-level, and if holding four-card support then he does not hold the sort of shape which would have led to a losing trick count of eight or the addition of further points for shortage which might have suggested a higher raise in the first place.


Just as a by-the-way I am a fan of the philosophy which throws the burden back onto responder.

If he had any interest in a game contract facing a 16-point balanced hand then he should have done something more exciting than raise to two at his first opportunity.


With this thought in mind your instinct with sixteen points should be to pass.

Basically you will only do anything else if the hand contains all sorts of strong features on the side - in other words a hand which you always thought was worth seventeen points in the first place.


Note that the fact that you had originally intended to rebid in no trumps on your fifteen or sixteen points facing a change of suit response does not amount to a good reason for taking such action now that partner has limited his hand.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 7 6

K Q 7 6

K 8 6

K 3

Pass.

In general the balanced sixteen point hand should pass when facing a limited raise to the two-level.  

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








with seventeen or eighteen points

you will bid 2NT, giving partner the choice of pass or three of the major with a minimum and 3NT or four of the major with a maximum.

Note that some authorities recommend bidding 2NT with seventeen points and 3NT with eighteen.  My feeling is that with a balanced hand, no great fit, and no quality five-card suit then the traditional seventeen or eighteen points is to be preferred, particularly if partner is likely to have raised on 5 points or fewer.  Add some other feature such as a good five-card suit or outstanding intermediates (nines and tens in particular) and I will be more likely to bid the game directly on eighteen points.


In general, following partner's raise to the 2-level, your bid of 2NT on a balanced hand of 17 or more points will promise just four cards in the major.

You could make this bid on a 5-card major in a balanced hand, but such a hand would have 5-3-3-2 shape and the presence of the doubleton would suggest a suit contract besed on the known 5-3 fit, in which case you will now treat the hand as unbalanced (as below).

However, with 4-4-3-2 shape and 17 or 18 points you will have little choice but to show the nature of the hand with 2NT.


and with nineteen points

and just a 4-card major in a balanced hand you will show your hand and force to game with 3NT.

In response to your 2NT bid partner will pass with a minimum and just 3-card support. He might also pass when holding 4-card support with minimum points in a 4-3-3-3 shape with little hope of any ruffing tricks in his hand, but against this you may well hold the doubleton so a correction to three of the major would still be a normal action.

With 4-card support and anything other than a flat shape in a minimum hand then he will sign off in 3 of the major.


Similarly with a maximum (a good 7 to 9) he will sign off in 3NT or four of the major.



Your major is five-card (or longer)


If your major is five-card you can be assured of an eight-card fit, and any final contract your way is likely to be played in that suit.


If your hand is no better than fifteen or sixteen points, or seven-loser, then your usual action will be to pass.


♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 7 6

K J 7 6

K Q 6

K 3

Bid 2NT,

promising seventeen (or eighteen) points in a balanced hand with just four hearts.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A K Q 5

K Q 7 6

7 6

K T 3

A pity about that weak diamond doubleton, but don’t let it stop you.

Just bid 2NT showing the strength and the balanced shape.


You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?









The short-suit trial bid


With this style of trial bid you bid a short suit, either singleton or void.

With losers in this suit partner will be able to upgrade his hand.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A Q

K T 6 5 3

K J T 9

9 4

Seven-loser hand with only thirteen HCP.

Pass.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








Beginner and above

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K Q 5

K Q 7 6

K 6

Q T 3

19 points in a balanced hand.

Bid 3NT.

Partner can still revert to 4♥ with 4-card support and a little shape.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 5

K Q J 9 3

6 5 3

8

Only 13 HCP, but 16 if you add on 3 for the singleton.

I value this hand as 6-loser and therefore invitational facing the minimum raise.

Playing natural trial bids, bid 2♠ promising a good suit and invitational values.


You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 5

K Q J 9 3

6 5 3

8

6-loser hand, as above.

Playing long suit trial bids bid 3♦ highlighting the potential losers in this suit.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 5

K Q J 9 3

6 5 3

8

6-loser hand, as above.

Playing short suit trial bids bid 3♣ showing the void or singleton in this suit.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 5

K Q J 9 3

6 5 3

8

6-loser hand, as above.

Bid 2♠ promising an invitational hand with a decent spade suit of at least four cards.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

6 5 3

K Q J 9 3

A K 8 5

8

6-loser hand, as above.

Bid 3♦ promising an invitational hand with a decent diamond suit.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

6 5

K Q J 9 8 3

A K

8 5 3

6-loser hand, as above.

Bid 3♣ the 'How good are you? bid' promising an invitational hand but denying a holding in diamonds or spades which would justify a natural trial bid.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

6 5

K Q J 9 8 3

A 4

8 5 3

a light opener with a good 6-card suit.

Bid 3♥ a pre-emptive raise to the level of the fit.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

2♥

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

K J T 9 8

A Q J 7

A 4

K 5 3

18 points or 6-loser.

Bid 3♥ a natural trial bid promising at least 5 spades, invitational values, and a respectable heart suit of four or more cards.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♠

-

2♠

-

?