Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Theory

Natural and shape-showing


Note that this page is about a specific style of trial bid - the ‘natural and shape-showing’ variety.


Follow this link  for an overview of trial bids and alternative options.


This style of trial bid is occasionally (but misleadingly) referred to as a ‘long-suit trial bid’.

It is a description which I try to avoid in the present context.  The term is more commonly, and in my view more correctly, applied to an alternative style which may be found via this link.


The shape-showing trial bid considered on this page is the most natural and intuitive style.


It is recommended as the starting method in all relevant situations when you first introduce trial bids into your partnership methods.

It will continue to serve you well if you choose to continue to use this style in the majority of such situations as you refine and develop your partnership methods, and it will be the recommended style in at least one specific type of auction.


In principle this shape-showing trial bid is a natural bid - usually the same strain that you would have rebid if partner had made a simple change of suit response.  As such it suggests at least four cards.


It should also promise at least a modicum of quality in the trial suit.

The specific requirements regarding high-card strength can vary by partnership agreement.  Critically, they should be clearly enough defined to assist partner in knowing whether his broken holding the suit improves his hand.  My suggestion is that the suit should contain at least two of the four top honours, but this is far from universal - you may well stretch this requirement to include holdings such as A T 9 x.


Partner raised your one of a major to the two-level


A new suit at the three-level (or 2♠ after 1♥ - 2♥) is a game-try trial bid.

It agrees the major and must therefore imply five cards in the major as partner’s raise might be no more than three-card.


As it offers partner the choice of signing off at the three-level or bidding the game it should promise something in the region of seventeen or eighteen points (or six losing tricks).

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K J T 4

8 7 6 5 4

K Q

T

Not the greatest thirteen points ever, but it is a six-loser hand.

I tend to downgrade it and pass with only limited prospects in your long side-suit, but if you feel that game is still a realistic possibility then lie just a little with a trial bid of 3♥.


You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♠

-

2♠

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q T 5 3

A 7

A J 9 8

K 5

Bid 4♠ directly based on a five-loser hand.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♠

-

2♠

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

K 7 6

Q 6 4 3

9 5 3

Q J 8

Eight points is middle of the range, and the shape is not good, but the club suit is beginning to look like a potential source of tricks.

Bid 4♥.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

-

2♥

-

3♣

-

?




♠

♥

♦

♣

K 7 6

Q 6 4 3

Q J 8

9 5 3

Eight points is middle of the range, and the shape is not good.

Partner’s club bid has not enhanced your hand in any way.

Sign off in 3♥.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

-

2♥

-

3♣

-

?




♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q T 5 3

A J 9 8

A 7

K 5

You could certainly bid 4♠ directly based on a five-loser hand.

Better is to make a natural trial-bid of 3♥.

You might find a superior 4-4 heart fit on your way to a game-contract.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♠

-

2♠

-

?









This style of trial bid will very occasionally locate a better strain in which to play.  on the whole this will apply when you hold 5-4 shape in the major suits.


A 4-4 fit will not infrequently produce 1 more trick than the 5-3 fit already located.


Partner raised your one of a major to the three-level


As any bid at this point will commit you to at least a game contract then your bid in a new suit must be a slam-try trial bid.

Partner’s raise promises at least four-card support, and so four cards in your major will be sufficient.


You can place partner with up to about twelve points, or an eight-loser hand.

You will therefore need to hold something like eighteen points or a hand worth five losers or better.


Note that this natural style of trial bid is the recommended style in this specific situation, identifying as it does a potential source of extra tricks if the hands fit.


Following partner’s raise to the two-level your trial bid will normally promise five cards in your first suit and four cards in the trial suit.


There are, though, two situations in which you might not be able to live up to this promise.


With 4-4-4-1 shape you can show a second four-card suit, but you will fail to deliver on your five-card holding in the first suit.  Hope to locate a better fit, but be prepared to play in a 4-3 fit - sometimes an enterprising jump to game or a splinter bid will prove a better choice.


And secondly, with a long suit you might not have a second four-card suit to show.

For this reason you will have to make your trial bid in a three-card suit on occasion.  That’s fine, but expect partner to read you for four cards in the first instance.  With 6-3-3-2 shape, it is worth noting that the sixth trump is all but worth an extra trick, and there is much to be said for just bidding the major suit game a point or two light.

5-3-3-2 shape is something of a special case.  If partner holds a flat hand (4-3-3-3 shape) with next to no ruffing potential then 3NT will sometimes play better than four of the major.  With this thought in mind you might sometimes choose to rebid in no trumps if your high cards are well-placed in the side-suits, but usually you will be able to do no better than make your trial bid in a three-card suit as above.  Note that such a trial bid should still promise the agreed honour holding.  Without it you should probably not be looking for a higher contract - better just to bid what you think you can make.


Responder’s actions


As with any trial bid responder will sign off in the lowest level of the agreed suit with a minimum (unless the trial bid has enhanced the holding out of all proportion), and make some other positive move (such as a jump to game) with a maximum.


If his hand lies between these extremes he should determine the potential of the two hands based on the information contained in the trial bid, and this will clearly depend on what you have promised with your trial bid.


Typically his hand will improve if either he has a good holding in the trial suit together with an honour or two (thereby creating a secondary source of tricks), or if he holds a shortage in that suit and ideally four trumps.  In this case the suit will either offer discards, or more frequently the opportunity to ruff two or three of partner’s losers.

This page last revised 27th Jan 2021

Context  -  Acol bidding - conventions - trial bids.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q T 5 3

A 7

A J 9 8

K 5

Slam is still very possible needing just a few well-placed cards in partner’s hand.

Bid 4♦ - forcing to game, expressing a slam interest, and showing a potential source of tricks

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♠

-

3♠

-

?