M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Responders rebid

root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Opener’s rebid

This page last updated 27th Apr 2021

Beginner and above

♠

♥

♦

♣

K J 8 5 4 2

Q 8 2

7 3

9 5

Playing option 1 (trial bids) you will probably bid 3♠ (preemptive).

Playing option 2 (no trump stops) your usual action will be to pass, although you might just venture a preemptive jump to 4♠ when not vulnerable.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

K T 8 4 3

A Q J

J 3 2

6 2

Eleven points - five spades.

Playing option 1 (trial bids) bid 3♥ (natural) or 3♦ (long suit).

Playing option 2 (no trump stops) bid 3♠ (invitational).


LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

K T 8 4 3

Q J 7

A 2

A 7 2

Five spades - seven-loser hand (or 14 points).

Bid 4♠.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

K T 8 3

7 5 2

A 6

9 7 5 2

You are at the bottom end of your range, so decline the invitation.

Pass.


LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

3♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q 8 3

7 5 2

A 6

J 7 5 2

Certainly enough to try for game opposite sixteen points in partner’s hand.

Bid 4♠.


LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

3♠

-

?






Partner raised to game


Usually you will, of course, pass, but you will not need a lot extra to see the possibility of a slam.

RKCB and various varieties of trial bid are available.


Partner made a splinter raise


The auction will already in effect be at game-level.  The only reason, therefore, for doing anything other than correct to the agreed suit will be that there is the still the possibility of a slam.  Bear in mind that partner’s bid promises the offensive potential for a realistic game bid (five losers or less), but that he will not necessarily be full value in HCP for a raise to this level.

Broadly speaking you should keep the bidding open if you hold fifteen or more points in a balanced hand or you are six-loser or better in an unbalanced hand.


Clearly RKCB (or Kickback) is available, but it will more often be correct to keep the bidding open with a bid in an intermediate suit, if any.


Various styles of trial bid are available.  You should agree your partnership style taking into particular account consistency with your methods in other situations for ease of memory.


Whatever your agreed style of trial bid in general I would strongly recommend that with only one intervening bid available you should use a ‘how good are you?’ bid, expecting partner to carry on if he is full value in high cards, or six-loser or better.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K T 8 4

Q J 7

A 3 2

A 7 2

Fourteen points - balanced hand - only four spades - and something in every suit.

Bid 3NT.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

K J 8 5

K T 2

5 3

Q 9 4 2

You have a spade fit which might be no better than 4-3 and a combined total of twenty four points at best.

Pass.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

K 9 8 5

K T 2

Q 5 3

K 4 2

Eleven points in a balanced hand, only four spades, and something in every suit.

Bid 2NT (invitational).

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 8 5

K T 2

K Q 5 3

5 4 2

Thirteen points in a balanced hand, only four spades, but no satisfactory stop in clubs.

Playing option 1 (trial bids) bid 3NT, giving nothing away.

Playing option 2 (no trump stops) bid 3♥ and wait to see whether or not partner can cover the clubs.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 8 5

K T 2

K 8 5 3

5 4 2

This is the hand on which you are not strong enough to bid out the stops.

Bid 2NT.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

2♠

-

?






With four cards in your major


you cannot be certain of anything better than a 4-3 fit.


Certainly you can pass with a minimum responding hand.


2NT will promise just four cards in the major and invitational values,  but will not necessarily promise a stop in any unbid suit;


3NT will promise just four cards in the major and game-going values:-

playing option two (no trump stops) it will also promise stops in any unbid suit;

playing option 1 (trial bids) it is possible that the unbid suits will not be stopped.


in the specific sequence 1♥, 1♠, 2♠   3♥ will promise just four spades and three hearts, and is most constructively played as forcing.


Slam interest?


In the fairly unlikely circumstance that you have a slam interest even after partner’s limited rebid then a jump in a new suit would be a splinter promising five cards in your major and a shortage in the splinter suit, and 4NT is best played as RKCB (or kickback).


Partner raised to the three-level


Partner’s support at the three-level promised four-card support, and typically sixteen or more points (or a six-loser hand).


You will finish in a contract in the major suit - the only question is how many.


You won’t need much extra to raise to game - a good eight points or an eight-loser hand will be quite sufficient.


Slam options will be as above, with the extra possibility of starting with a bid in a new suit and then correcting from 3NT to show a slam interest and start a cue-bidding sequence.

Context  -  Responder’s rebid - partner opened one of a suit - RHO passed - you changed suit initially - LHO passed - partner raised your suit.

One anything - one major - raise of the major


This page addresses the sequences one minor - one major - raise of the major, as well as the sequences 1♥ - 1♠  - raise of spades.


Partner raised to the two-level


Partner’s may well have four or more-card support, but he has not promised more than three.

His hand will be limited to a maximum of fifteen or so points.


Bid in a new suit


Your methods will revolve around the meaning you assign to a bid in a new suit.


Clearly such a bid would be useful as some sort of game-try trial bid inviting partner to choose between part-score and game in the major, but equally, it could be invaluable as a means of showing a stop in a side-suit as you search for a no trump contract.


And it’s no good just ignoring the problem and allowing the bid to mean whatever you want it to mean at the time.

The whole point of a bidding system is that your bids will have meanings and that your partner can judge his next move based on that meaning.


You have three options:-


1. the bid is first and foremost a trial bid.


Putting all other considerations aside this would be an excellent use of the bid:-


it is consistent with opener’s action on his rebid after partner has raised his opening one of a major to the two-level, and it works well as such whenever your major is five-card;


it also releases the re-raise to the three-level as a preemptive manoeuvre.


The downside is that with just four cards in your major you will frequently find yourself having to bid 2NT or 3NT with totally inadequate stops in at least one of the side-suits.


2. the bid is first and foremost a no trump stop.


Way back in the 1970s Eric Crowhurst counselled that it should always promise a no trump stop (Precision bidding in Acol).


This certainly works well enough, leaving the re-raise to the three-level as natural and invitational - not quite as scientific as a trial bid, but at least you have all your bases covered.


3. you come up with a conventional method which in some ways covers both of the ideas above.


This would perhaps be along the lines of an artificial bid of 2NT asking partner to identify his strength and his trump length.


A possible set of responses might be:-


3♣    three-card trump support, minimum;

3♦    four-card trump support, minimum;

3♥    three-card trump support, maximum;

3♠    four-card trump support, maximum.


A refinement would be to play 2NT in this way when spades are the agreed major, but to play 2♠ as the conventional bid when hearts are the agreed suit, lowering all the continuations accordingly.


Following such a routine you will frequently be able to select the final contract, and in some sequences you might be able to make a further bid showing a no trump stop.


Which method?


On earlier versions of this page I suggested that it should always be a trial bid.


Now I am not so sure.

It is far from clear to me which of these systems is theoretically best - it may well depend on the form of scoring - and I am not aware of a clear consensus in the expert world at the present time.


I rather like option 1 (trial bids) with its accuracy in bidding a contract in the major suit.

(it is, though, worth pointing out that when you use a trial bid following an opening bid of one of a major there is quite a high probability that your major will be five-card - the probability is lower when you bid one major as a first response).


A missing stop in a side-suit is by no means the end of the world in 2NT, and even in 3NT there is something to be said for just bidding the contract without telling the opponents where your weaknesses lie.

In either case partner will of course correct to the major with four cards in the suit - on other occasions he will provide something of a stop in a weak suit - and once in a while the opponents might miss the killing lead or their suit might split or block.


Option 2 (no trump stops) is perhaps the easiest to play.


The reraise to the three-level to show the invitational hand in the major is less precise than the trial bid approach but it is not the end of the world, and it is reassuring to know about stops in the side-suits.

A bid of 2NT promises four cards in the major and invitational values - it may or may not promise stops in any unbid suit which cannot be shown at the two-level,

but a bid of 3NT promises four cards in the major, game-going values, and at least something of a stop in any unbid suit.


An optional extra in the sequences 1 minor, 1♥, 2♥ is that 2♠ should be artificial and forcing for one round showing just four hearts and at least invitational values, but denying stops in both side-suits.


Option 3 (a conventional approach) will certainly appeal to some,


but you will miss the natural bid of 2NT (particularly at pairs scoring), and following a 3♣ response you will on occasion find yourself having to choose between three of the major on a 4-3 fit and 3NT on inadequate values.

Furthermore I am not totally certain that knowing whether partner has three- or four-card support is as helpful as you might assume - simply bid as if he has three and he will correct if he has four.

You may choose to work on some conventional method along the lines suggested but it’s another convention to learn, remember and recognize, and for me of only limited value - others may know better.


Feel free to make your own choice - but in the following I shall confine my attention to options one and two.


With five cards in your major


you will have established an eight-card fit - it will be rare that your target contract is not in that suit.


With less than ten points and nothing exceptional by way of shape (no better than a nine-loser hand):-

it will usually be correct to pass at this point,

although playing option 1 (trial bids) you might re-raise preemptively to the three-level with six trumps.


With about ten or eleven points after suitable re-evaluation, or about eight losers:-

playing option 1 (trial bids)you will make your agreed style of trial bid inviting partner to choose between three and four of the major;

playing option 2 (no trump stops) you will re-raise to the three-level promising a five-card suit and invitational values.


With about twelve points after re-evaluation (or a seven-loser hand) you will bid game in the major, although you might on occasion make the same bid on a weaker hand with seven or so cards in the major.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 3

A 9 5

9 8 2

A 6 2

Partner’s diamond shortage sits well facing your weak holding.

Slam must be at least a possibility.

Bid 4♥ - a ‘How good are you?’ bid, suggesting either fifteen points or a six-loser hand.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♥

-

1♠

-

4♦

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 3

K Q 9

Q J 4

9 8 6

Partner’s club shortage sits well facing your weak holding.

Slam must be at least a possibility.

Bid 4♥ - promising a control in hearts and denying a control in diamonds.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♥

-

1♠

-

4♣

-

?





♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 8 3

9 8 6

Q J 4

K Q 9

Partner’s heart shortage sits well facing your weak holding.

Assume that partner is full value for his splinter into the next lower suit.

Slam must be at least a possibility.

Bid 4NT - RKCB.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♦

-

1♠

-

4♥

-

?





Intermediate and above

Something experimental


In the sequence 1♥, 1♠, 2♠ the following method is original in as much as I have thought it out for myself, but it seems likely that someone else might have got there before me, and to the best of my knowledge it has not been tested at the highest level.


Retain the natural bids of 2NT, 3NT

and the preemptive raise to 3♠;

3♥ will promise three hearts and four spades;

3♣ will also promise three hearts and four spades;

3♦ is a ‘how good are you?’ trial bid with five spades.


Of the two sequences promising three hearts and four spades one will be forcing only as far as 3♥, and the other will be game-forcing.


I play the slow route via 3♣ as the stronger.


I think that this works well and without too much complication, but it is one of those conventions which applies to only one specific auction - you won’t lose out very often if you dispense with it, and most of the other variations above, and stick to the natural approach.