Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Theory

Protective seat


Protective bidding in general is discussed in the section considerations and principles.


In general you will not want your opponents to get away with a one-level contract, particularly as there is a fair chance that the deal belongs to your side - the chances of this yielding a good score for you are fairly minimal, particularly at pairs scoring.


The conclusion is simple - in this position you should strive to find a bid, even with a hand on which you would neither open nor overcall in the immediate overcall seat:-


suits might be bid on substandard quality holdings - even sometimes on a four-card suit at the one-level;

a take-out double may be made on as few as nine points (some say eight) if the shape is perfect.  Don’t stretch it any further than this in this specific situation - partner must have some guarantee of strength if he is considering a penalty pass;

the 1NT overcall is usually downgraded from about fifteen to eighteen to something like eleven to fifteen.


But if a suit overcall is based on a six-card or longer holding, or on a good five-card suit, then points hardly come into it.

Your mantra should be more along the lines of ‘anything goes’, as you strive to protect the probable/possible holding in partner’s hand.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 6

A K 7 5 2

Q T 3

8 5 4

LHO opened 1♠ followed by two passes.

Bid 2♥ when not vulnerable.

You would prefer an extra heart or an extra heart honour for a direct overcall at the two-level, but I wouldn’t hesitate to show this suit in the protective seat.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 6

Q J T 7 5 2

T 9 3

5 4

LHO opened 1♠ followed by two passes.

Bid 2♥ when not vulnerable.

Perhaps you would like a little more when vulnerable, but otherwise this is a clear protective overcall for me (though possibly not everyone).

Beginner and above

Advancer’s next bid

This page last revised 7th Sept 2021


Clearly this is an oversimplification.

A little more circumspection will be appropriate if vulnerable and contemplating an overcall at the two-level, but the principle is clear.

♠

♥

♦

♣

T 8 7 6 3

K Q 5

Q T 3

6 2

LHO opened 1♣ followed by two passes.

Not much of a hand and not much of a suit, but I bid 1♠ in the protective seat at pairs.

Agree as a partnership whether or not you would make this bid vulnerable or at teams scoring.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q 8 3

6 4 2

Q T 3

T 7 5

LHO opened 1♥ followed by two passes.

Not much of a hand and only four spades, but consider bidding 1♠ in the protective seat when not vulnerable at pairs.


You hold the spades


Playing at pairs you will only rarely get rich defending an undoubled contract at the one-level.

In particular, if your side holds the spades you will frequently win the part-score battle, and one down not vulnerable will often prove to be an excellent score -  even two down could score a top.

Context - overcaller - opponents opened one of a suit (natural) - new suit at the lowest level.

Question

My guideline

How strong should I be to overcall in the protective seat?

At the risk of rather overstating the case, the minimum requirement for a one-level suit overcall in the protective seat is in the region of ‘thirteen cards’.


You might find yourself in the protective seat at some later point in the auction.


You should be even more inclined to compete provided that the auction is still at a suitably low level.

The possibility of a planned penalty pass facing your double has now more or less disappeared, both opponents will have limited their hands, and if they have found any sort of fit then there is an increased likelihood that your side will also have something of a fit.


A bid in no trumps will be rare in this scenario, but you may certainly introduce a pretty feeble suit at the two-level, and a take-out double might stretch as low as seven points providing that the shape, the level and the vulnerability are all in your favour.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K J 5 3

8 2

K 6 5 4

T 5 2

There must be an excellent chance of an eight-card spade fit at the two-level, and diamonds at the three-level wouldn’t be terrible.

Double when not vulnerable.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO


1♣

-

1♥

-

2♥

-

-

?