Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Theory

Beginner and above

Protective seat


At any point in the auction, after LHO has bid and both partner and RHO have passed, you will be in the ‘protective’ seat, although the term is frequently limited to the situation in which LHOs bid was the opening bid.

The present page confines its attention to this situation in which the opening bid is followed by two passes.  A brief consideration of other situations in which the auction peters out at a low level and is followed by two passes will be found on the page bidding in the protective seat.


Why protective?


There are two situations in which you would really like to bid in the overcalling seat but in which there is no suitable bid available.


The first of these is when you hold something like an opening 1NT hand with stops in the opponents’ suit.  You would love to overcall but you do not hold the requisite fifteen or more points.  You must pass.


The second is when you hold a (possibly) slightly weaker hand with length (say five or more cards) in the opponents suit.  Once again you would like either to double for penalties (but such a bid would be for take-out), or bid 1NT (but such a bid would promise fifteen points).


In either case you can do no better than pass.


Fear not.  If partner has anything at all even vaguely worth talking about then he must find a bit in the protective seat - he will protect against the possibility that you have one of these holdings.


If his protective bid happens to be a take-out double you may well be able to make a penalty pass for a lucrative score your way.

This page last revised 5th Sept 2021

♠

♥

♦

♣

K T 9 7 5

A 8

K 5 3 2

A 9

RHO opened 1♠.  Shame - he took your bid.

Just pass.

If the hand is passed round to partner and he doubles you will be more than happy to defend the doubled contract.


Alternatively, if neither of you is able to enter the auction subsequently then you will be happy to defend in the knowledge that your opponents are not going to find this an easy contract, and there is probably not much on your way either.


Protective bidding


The position is also sometimes referred to as the ‘balancing seat’, and Andrew Robson uses the delightfully descriptive term ‘cheat seat’ which pretty much tells you everything about it.


Partner might have one of the two holdings suggested above in which case he will be hoping desperately that you can find a bid, but in any case you will also harbour the thought that ‘I’m not going to let them get away with a nice easy contract at the one- (or two-) levels’.  There will be occasions when this is the right thing to do, but in general it will pay to compete - after all you will always have at least a seven-card fit somewhere.


In particular, if LHO opened one of a suit, typically on a range of about eleven to nineteen, then responder is unlikely to hold more than five points.  It is true that your opponents might hold about 19 facing 5, but more often they will hold something like 14 facing 4, which leaves your side with twenty two.  If you haven’t got them then partner has.

So find a bid if you can.


An old rule of thumb which tends to get passed down from generation to generation in clubs is to ‘borrow a king’ - i.e. bid with up to three points less than you might have done in the immediate overcall position.

As with many such easy guidelines it encapsulates a basic truth whilst grossly oversimplifying the situation.


Certainly a double must promise some values just in case partner is contemplating a penalty pass.  In the immediate overcall position you might double for take-out on as few as eleven points (or thereabouts) if the shape were near ideal - say 4-4-4-1.  In this case, ‘borrow a king’ is a good guideline and so you might double on as few as eight with excellent shape.


Similarly an overcall of 1NT could leave leave you fatally exposed if the opponents are maximum for their bidding, and partner may well be interested in a penalty double should the opponents show any further disrespect, so ‘borrow a king’ and overcall 1NT in the protective seat on something like twelve to fifteen.  Some would take the lower limit down to eleven, but don’t go any further than this.


But if you are contemplating a suit bid then the world’s your oyster - a five-card suit at the one- or two-levels is all you need, and at the one-level you might even overcall on a four-card suit.


The arguments are similar when the opponents open a weak bid such as a weak two.  Your underlying thought should still be ‘they’re not going to scare me off that easily’, although if your bid might take your partnership to the three-level there should be some sort of quality in your hand.


However, the argument is rather less clear cut if they opened something different - particularly a limited bid such as 1NT.  In this particular case it is perfectly possible that the opponents may hold as many as twenty four points between them, partner will not be waiting to make a penalty pass, and quite simply the concept of the protective seat doesn’t really exist.

There is still good reason to try to get into the auction at this point on a suitable holding rather than leaving them to play in a nice easy contract at the one-level, but you should take a slightly less cavalier approach.


Your actions following LHOs opening one of a suit are considered in a little more detail in the context of each of your most likely bids:-


double


1NT


suit overcall at the lowest level


jump suit overcall


Context - overcaller - considerations and principles.