The bidding
NS
The South hand is better than its nine points suggest.
With three-card support for partner and a singleton this hand has considerable offensive potential, and with the points working well together it is not without defensive strength.
Indeed, with a seven-loser hand in support of hearts you have your eyes on game, and so you must not make a bid which can be passed.
If you are happy to make a good raise based on three-card support then bid 3♦ (the cue-raise, sometimes referred to as the unassuming cue-bid) - otherwise it’s a natural and forcing change of suit with 3♣ - a bit pushy but you can’t allow the auction to die.
3♥ at his second attempt certainly suggest a fourth heart but the final double is well-judged.
North is worth at least 3♥ at his second turn with a known nine-card fit and a six-loser hand. He might even hazard a trial bid - 2♠ perhaps - which should elicit a game raise from East.
East is certainly good enough for an overcall, but 2♦ is a bit tame. Facing a passed hand there is unlikely to be a slam and so there is an argument for underplaying the strength and jumping to 3♦ - this will certainly give South a bit of a headache.
4♦ would certainly risk pushing the opponents into a making game, but you might be thinking of bidding 5♦ over a possible 4♥ contract then the best bid would be an immediate jump to 5♦. It will certainly stop the opponents locating a fit, and on a good day it might avoid a double, though probably not on this occasion.
If not vulnerable against vulnerable I would jump to 5♦ immediately.
However, the danger of 3 down doubled and vulnerable is just too great - my choice is an immediate overcall of 3♦, and leave it at that.
The play
The contract is 5♦x with South on lead.
Declarer can count seven top tricks and a club ruff for a likely eighth, but when the ♣K falls a second club brings the total to nine.
What happened?
Hearts made ten tricks at four tables and eleven tricks at four table with one 9 and one 12 - 620 or 650 to NS.
Diamonds made ten tricks twice and nine tricks four times - 500 to NS.
On the day 5♦ was an excellent bid, but it will make eight tricks far more often than it will make nine, and the risk of -800 is too great to take.
Not every NS pair bid the game and one pair didn’t double 5♦, and so 5♦x-1 needed some luck to make 9 tricks but was a little unlucky to score just 46.7% on the actual lie of the cards.