My partner sitting East opened 1♠ and I responded 2♦.
East certainly has greater playing strength than its eleven points might suggest, but for me it is not strong enough for a high reverse.
I put in a 4th suit bid of 3♥ to see what else I might learn, and partner bid 3NT, presumably reading me for hearts - I have hearts but I haven’t shown them. 4♣ would have described the hand better.
W
N
E
S
1♠
-
2♦
-
3♣
-
?
Context - Acol bidding - hands - post mortems.
The bidding continues
Lacking the machinery to determine the quality of partner’s trump holding I jumped to the small slam of 6♣.
Certainly this was a gamble, particularly taking the quality of my club suit into account, but with an expectation of another four or so points in partner’s hand and a holding which was in all other respects eminently suited to a slam contract I thought it a risk worth taking.
The play
The lead of the ♦J gives declarer an immediate decision as there is an all but certain trump loser, but with prospects of something of a cross-ruff and the possibility of a long diamond or spade (or both) the correct action is to take the Ace, followed by two rounds of hearts ditching the losing diamond (finessing the diamond works and makes the rest of your life easier, but it is not a risk worth taking).
Time to take stock. What you cannot afford is a third round of trumps, so you must avoid losing the second round of trumps.
So start by taking the obvious finesse in clubs then leading out the Ace. They are always going to make the ♣K, but leave it out - don’t waste 2 trumps on it.
Then, spade to the Ace, ruff a diamond, ♠K throwing the heart, ruff a spade ruff dropping the Queen, diamond ruff, ♠J throwing a diamond, spade ruff, and the last spade is good - they can take their trump whenever they like.
What happened?
3NT made 11 tricks at five tables, ten tricks at three tables and 9 tricks at three tables. 6NT also made just eleven tricks at one table.
Which leaves us with a rather sad 2♠ by East making ten tricks, a 5♦ contract by West making just eight tricks, a 5♣ contract by East making twelve tricks, and our 6♣ contract - one off for a joint bottom.
It’s clearly not a sound contract - if the club finesse fails you will almost certainly lose a second trump trick - and the bidding was far from scientific at best, but 6♣ making would have given us a very nice top.