M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Responders rebid

root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Opener’s rebid

♠

♥

♦

♣

T 9 4

Q J 9 8 6

2

K 8 7 5

Bid 2♣.

If partner is kind enough to respond 2♥ you will be able to pass.

Otherwise you will sign off with 3♣ - weak.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

1♥

-

1NT

-

?






with thirteen or more points responder will force to game (opposite a minimum of twelve points), usually with a direct raise to 3NT or with a natural and forcing suit-bid at the three-level;

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 4

Q J 9 8 6

K 9 7 2

K 8

Bid 3♦ (natural and forcing).


LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

1♥

-

1NT

-

?






An immediate rebid of 2NT promises a balanced hand of eleven or twelve points.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 9 4

J T 9 7

K 6 2

K 8 5

Bid 2NT showing both your strength and your shape.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

1♥

-

1NT

-

?






So why don’t I love it?


Usually I speak of Eric Crowhurst in the hushed tones of deepest reverence.

He was the first to analyse the various possible Acol bidding sequences in depth in a systematic manner, and in so doing he introduced many ideas which are still of paramount importance in good bidding practice.


However, as indicated at the top of this page, I am not a fan of the convention which bears his name.

It is in fairly common use in club bridge and to an extent at higher levels, and its proponents include many who are without doubt considerably better players than I am.  If you choose to join their number you will be in good company.


Quite simply, and I stress that this is just my personal view on the matter, the Crowhurst convention has been overtaken by the passage of time and the introduction of new styles and an improved approach to bidding balanced hands.


Crowhurst introduced his convention at a time when common Acol practice still retained something of the outlook associated with a strong no trump and five-card majors.


First, there was an extreme reluctance to open 1NT on a hand containing a marked weakness - typically a small doubleton.

This consideration made sense in the world of the strong no trump.  With fifteen or more points it was an eminently reasonable requirement that you should have some sort of holding in every suit.

But, when there are only twelve points to be spread around four suits, a weak suit is all but inevitable.  Indeed, a balanced hand containing, say, three points in each suit has little to commend it - you would much prefer to see some solidity somewhere, with the inevitable weakness somewhere else.  A weak suit will be the norm, and it is not something of which to be afraid at the one-level.  If left it will not be the end of the world as you watch your opponents take the first six tricks in that suit before you mop up the rest of the hand, and if the bidding progresses beyond the one-level then there will be time in which to locate matching strengths or weaknesses.


The second significant factor was that it was standard practice at that time to open the minor if holding two four-card suits. This was a relic of a five-card major outlook, and a reluctance to open on a four-card major suit.  These days it far more common (though by no means universal) to open one of a major, if held, in a 4-4-3-2 hand.


A linked tendency was to open 1♣ on a four-card (and quite frequently less) suit and to rebid in another good four-card suit.  The emphasis lay in showing the location of the high cards.  The modern preference to emphasise shape is a step forward.  Sequences in which opener starts with 1♣ and then rebids in a major are now taken to promise at least a five-card holding in the first bid suit, and I believe this interpretation to be a better use of the sequence.

Even when opening a decent five-card suit in a twelve to fourteen point hand there can be problems.  If that five-card suit happens to be clubs then the approach works really well.  As it happens most of Crowhurst’s own example hands feature an opening bid of 1♣, and everything works out quite beautifully.  But if that suit is not clubs and responder forces you to a rebid at the two-level on only twelve or thirteen points then life can suddenly get very difficult.  Frequently you will have to rebid that five-card suit.  The modern practice of opening or rebidding in no trumps whenever a balanced hand is held, even when it contains a weak doubleton, ensures that to open a suit and rebid in that suit will promise a six-card holding on the great majority of occasions. This is a particularly valuable piece of information.

Throw in the advent of transfer methods to locate long suits in responder’s hand and a partnership agreement to raise an opening one of a major to the two-level on three-card support when no better bid exists, and most of the reasons for the convention have disappeared.


It’s not that there’s anything wrong with the Crowhurst convention - it’s just that, as I see it, it has little purpose any more, and there are better ways of improving your methods.  In particular it fails to address the problem of locating the best contract on a nineteen point hand.


I looked recently at the nine example hands in one of Crowhurst’s own writings on the subject (Precision Bidding in Acol). (This is, by the way, a work which I very much admire.)  In each case I compared the bidding using the Crowhurst convention and also using modern standard methods.


On eight out of the nine hands opener was able to start with 1♣ when using the Crowhurst approach.  His argument is immediately skewed by this choice.

Out of the nine hands only three contracts were identical.  A fourth deal could finish in either 3♥ or 4♥, depending on judgement, using either approach.  One hand was able to finish in a 2♣ part-score by natural methods rather than a dubious 3♣.  On two deals the same major suit contracts were reached - one a part-score and one a game, but modern transfer methods had the advantage of putting the play into the stronger hand, and on the remaining two deals modern transfer methods left declarer playing in two of a major on a 5-2 fit rather than in 2NT - I have a slight preference for the major suit contract.  Altogether, not a very convincing set of examples.


So, open the major when holding two four-card suits in a balanced hand - don’t be afraid to raise partner’s one of a major on three-card support in a weak hand if no better bid exists - incorporate red-suit transfers at the very least - don’t be afraid to open a weak balanced hand with 1NT, even if there is a pronounced weakness and your points are concentrated in two suits -and you will find it difficult to identify the advantages in playing this convention.


Please don’t forget that much of the point of opening with a weak no trump lies in its preemptive effect. Start by opening 1♣ on some (or most) 12-14 point hands which could have been opened 1NT, and much of this preemptive value has been lost.


By all means adopt this method if you wish - I just feel that you can do better, but, as ever, it’s up to you.


And, just to complete the story, there are other ranges which are at least equally effective.

My own feeling is that the modern standard in which opener’s 1NT rebid promises 15 to 17 points, thereby allowing a 2NT rebid on eighteen or nineteen points is a clear improvement.


Alternatively try the modern tournament method in which wide-ranging a 1NT rebid promises a wide-ranging fifteen to eighteen points with its own associated set of extensions.

This page last revised 14th May 2021


You will have noted that I have included a response of 2♠ by opener in the possibilities on the sequence in the example above.

If partner holds five clubs and four spades then he should have rebid 1♠ rather than 1NT.

If he holds four clubs and four spades then the sequence above might happen if your partnership agreement is to open the minor, but it would be an impossible auction if your partnership agreement is to open the major.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 9 8 6

A T 4

K 5

8 7 2

Bid 2♣ (Crowhurst - artificial and forcing).  If partner responds 2NT (forcing) you will show your three hearts with 3♥.  With only four hearts but with three spades partner will then bid 3♠.

After 2♥ or 2♠ you will pass, and opposite 2♦ you will sign off in 2NT.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♥

-

1♠

-

1NT

-

?






Responder’s alternative rebids are:-


with up to eight points responder will sign off (opposite a maximum of sixteen points), either by passing, by rebidding his first suit or opener’s first suit, or by bidding a new lower-ranking suit (unless you play it as forcing).

♠

♥

♦

♣

T 9 4

Q J 9 8 6

K 8 7 5

2

Bid 2♦, showing the 5-4 shape in the red suits in a weak hand.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

1♥

-

1NT

-

?






If your weak sign-off is in clubs then you will have to start with a Crowhurst 2♣ and follow with 3♣ as a weak sign-off.

12 to 16 point 1NT rebid


Note that the more common responding ranges of 15 to 17 or 15 or 16 have already been discussed elsewhere.


This method is particularly loved by those players who hate to open 1NT with a weak suit and/or feel a compelling urge to show a five-card suit at the earliest opportunity.

As you will see, I feel that this is an outdated approach which in my opinion has been overtaken by developments in standard Acol practice.

The method is to play a wide-ranging 1NT rebid, usually on a range of 12 to 16, thus allowing opener to commence proceedings on some balanced hands in the 12 to 14 range with one of a suit.


The Crowhurst convention


The method will almost invariably be combined with a version of the Crowhurst convention.

In this convention, 2♣ by responder following opener’s 1NT rebid is artificial and forcing.

In principle it promises ten or a goodish nine points (game-going opposite the stronger options) but it will sometimes be used on stronger holdings.  It asks opener to define his hand more precisely both in terms of strength and major suit holdings.

There are variations in detail in the methods employed by different partnerships but a typical set of agreements would go along the following lines:-


in responding to the artificial 2♣ bid opener will:-


bid 2NT with 15 or 16 points (game-forcing);

with 12 to 14 points he will do one of the following:-

bid partner’s major suit with three-card support;

rebid his own five-card major;

introduce a new four-card major;

bid 2♦ denying any of the above holdings.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A T 4

Q J 9 8 6

K 5

8 7 2

Bid 2♣ (Crowhurst - artificial and forcing).

If partner responds 2NT (forcing) you will show your fifth heart with 3♥.  If he bids 2♥ or 2♠ you will pass, and if he bids 2♦ you will sign off in 2NT.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1♣

-

1♥

-

1NT

-

?





Intermediate and above

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s rebid - partner opened one of a suit - RHO passed - you changed suit initially - LHO passed - partner rebid in no trumps - your first response was at the one-level - alternative ranges.