M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Responders rebid

root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory


These deals happen on occasion.  Usually the bidding will proceed much as shown above.  The defence will locate the weak suit as often as not, and the declaring partnership will dismiss it as ‘just one of those hands.’


But in each case there is a better contract available.


Hand 1

4♠ is a good contract on the 4-3 trump split.

The outstanding trumps will divide either 4-2 or 3-3 as much as 84% of the time, and the four missing diamonds will divide 2-2 or 3-1 90% of the time all else being equal.

Hand 2

4♥ is not cast-iron on the 5-2 fit, but it is a much surer bet than the no trump contract.

Hand 3

is not dissimilar.

There are significant differences here, not least that East’s hand is not balanced and alternative bids are available.

It is rare that a minor-suit game contract is preferable to a game in no trumps, but on this deal five of either minor is far preferable.


There is a common theme to these examples.

In all three cases there are matching shortages in the two hands.


Finishing in a 3NT contract with corresponding weak doubletons may be viewed as an occupational hazard, but can we take a more constructive view?

The questions are ‘Can these making contracts be bid?’ and ‘Should these contracts be bid?’


There are two possible approaches.


One is to incorporate sequences which identify weak doubletons.

We have already come across one convention in which this approach can be incorporated, and that was the 2NT transfer break (over a red-suit transfer) - one of the possible choices.

However, my view is that you should use the available bidding space primarily to locate fits rather than misfits - and this has been the underlying theme in all that has gone before.


The alternative approach is that, within a system which concentrates on locating fits, either member of the partnership is permitted to run for cover if he can foresee the possibility of a real problem.

In practice this means that either player, if holding a weak doubleton, can seek a safer contract than 3NT if he has no good reason to believe that his partner has the suit guarded.

Note that the player with a weak three-card holding will not take this initiative - if his partner has three small cards then 3NT will usually be as good a game-contract as any, and if his partner has the weak doubleton then the initiative can be left with him.


And what form does this initiative take?

In general it means preferring a 4-3 or 5-2 major suit fit or a minor-suit game whenever there is reason to believe that the no trump contract might fail.


With this approach in mind let us look again at alternative methods of bidding the three example hands.


Hand 1

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 8 6

K J 4

K Q 7 6 2

Q 4

Partner has denied a five-card major (if playing five-card Stayman).

When he shows four spades you can raise to 4♠ on the 4-3 fit rather than risk that club suit.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1NT

-

2♣

-

2♦

-

3♣

-

3♠

-

-


Hand 2

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 8 6

A K Q J 5

T 4

K 9 4

Did you even think about raising to 4♥?

You may only have a 5-2 fit, but can you risk that diamond suit in no trumps?

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1NT

-

2♦

-

2♥

-

?






Hand 3

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 6

A K

K Q 7 4

Q T 8 6 2

Frequently it is correct to take a stab at 3NT with a holding in either or both of the minor suits, but can you risk it with this spade holding?

Show your shape and strength with the transfer sequence shown, then it is up to partner.

LHO

Pard

RHO

You


1NT

-

2♠

-

3♣

-

3♦

-

?




Partner, with the hand below, might well choose the minor suit contract.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 5

Q 9 5

A 8 5 3

A K J 7

Partner has shown nine cards in the minors and therefore four at most in the majors.  One of them is likely to be wide-open.

3NT would not be a stupid gamble, but there is much to be said for choosing 5♣ (or 5♦).

LHO

Pard

RHO

You




1NT

-

2♠

-

3♣

-

3♦

-

?


The answer to my first question is clearly ‘Yes. These making contracts can be bid.’


The answer to the second question as to whether or not they should be bid is far more difficult.  You will not get a unanimous answer even from amongst a group of experts.  Certainly the approach suggested above takes you from a minor disaster to a making contract on the three example hands, but is there a danger that on another deal the escape from 3NT will take you in the reverse direction from a making contract into a disaster?


This is hand one again with the original West holding but with the bidding as above such that East directs to the contract of 4♠.

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


A K J 7

Q 9 5

A 8 5 3

9 5

West opens 1NT.  East asks with five-card Stayman, and follows this with 3♣ asking for four-card majors.

When West shows his spade suit East settles for 4♠ which will usually make ten tricks.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


Q 8 6

K J 4

K Q 7 6 2

Q 4


Now let us look at the same East hand and the same bidding but with West given an extra card in the weak suit.

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


A K J 7

Q 9 5

A 8 5

9 5 3

Once again the 3NT contract stands no chance on a club lead, whereas the 4♠ alternative depends on little more than a 4-2 trump split.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


Q 8 6

K J 4

K Q 7 6 2

Q 4


For the next variation I shall give West four small cards in the suit.

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


A K J 7

Q 9 5

A 5

9 8 5 3

Even now 3NT is in trouble on the likely 4-3 club split, provided that the opponents can avoid blocking the suit.

4♠ is not easy.  The diamonds are unlikely to establish and so declarer must negotiate a club ruff whilst maintaining control and entries.  But it is more likely than 3NT.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


Q 8 6

K J 4

K Q 7 6 2

Q 4


Now let us take another look at this deal when West holds a genuine stop in the danger suit.

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


K J 9 7

Q 9 5

A 8 5 3

A 5

The chances in 3NT depend mainly on the placement of the ♣K.

4♠ will make on a 4-2 split, provided that declarer can hold his trump losers to one.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


Q 8 6

K J 4

K Q 7 6 2

Q 4


And finally, what if we give West a genuine holding in the danger suit?

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


K J 9 7

9 5

A J 3

A J 8 5

This time 3NT is near certain, making ten tricks, unless South holds both the heart honours and North has at least one of the missing black suit honours as an entry.  4♠ will usually make the same ten tricks for a slightly inferior score at pairs. It could fail against a poor trump break but offers some protection against the heart problem.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


Q 8 6

K J 4

K Q 7 6 2

Q 4


Clearly I could look further at the other two example hands but I think it would add little to the analysis.


Does this analysis lead me to a clear conclusion?


No.


Whatever your choice you will win some and you will lose some.


My initial impression is that it is a close decision when playing at pairs because ten tricks in no trumps will outscore ten tricks in the suit contract on occasion.

However, the major suit contract on the 4-3 fit may well just have the edge at teams.  The contract will make more frequently - it just might not score quite as well.


This summary is far from an overwhelming argument one way or the other.

The probabilities regarding which holding partner is might likely to hold are far from simple to calculate.

I am still trying to look at the decision based on a large number of hands from actual play and I may yet change my opinion as a result of that, but for the moment I tend to favour the escape from 3NT when holding a weak doubleton and the partnership holds two balanced hands.

It is perhaps relevant to point out that in the example hands above I have given declarer sufficient trump honours to maintain control of the suit.  The arguments are much weaker when the 4-3 fit is based around a hollow holding.


On the next two pages you will find two hands which I have selected for the purpose.

They will not provide conclusive evidence one way or the other, but they will, I hope, provide worthwhile food for thought.


It is difficult to apportion blame for the disaster illustrated above.

The bidding is sensible - the contract appears to be reasonable - there is no eight-card major-suit fit available - and even if the partnership locates the diamond fit a contract of 5♦ is little better losing two clubs and a heart immediately.


Hand 2

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


A Q J 4

8 4

7 3 2

A J 8 5

Typically the bidding will go 1NT, 2♦, 2♥, 3NT.

Once again the contract is in considerable jeopardy.

On a diamond lead only a 4-4 split will save declarer from immediate disaster, and even then he has to locate a successful black-suit finesse to make his contract.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


9 8 6

A K Q J 5

T 4

K 9 4


Hand 3

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


9 5

Q 9 5

A 8 5 3

A K J 7

West opens 1NT and East raises to 3NT.

Twelve tricks are there for the taking, provided that the defence does not take five tricks in spades first.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


Q 6

A K

K Q 7 4

Q T 8 6 2

The seven-card fit and the minor suit game


When both hands are balanced the basic bidding rules are straightforward - both members of the partnership will search for an eight-card major-suit fit.  If they fail to locate one then the auction will come to rest in some suitable number of no trumps.


And most of the time this simple philosophy will lead to the optimum contract.


There are, though, particular sets of circumstances in which this approach fails to find the best spot.


Hand 1

W

♠

♥

♦

♣


A K J 7

Q 9 5

A 8 5 3

9 5

West opens 1NT.  East either raises directly to 3NT, or asks with five-card Stayman but when no five-card major comes to light he settles for 3NT.  Declarer can count eleven likely tricks (or nine without even losing the lead), when he gets in - but a well-organised defence should take five club tricks and the ♥A first.

E

♠

♥

♦

♣


Q 8 6

K J 4

K Q 7 6 2

Q 4

Context  -  Responder’s rebid - partner opened 1NT - RHO passed - intermediate and beyond - describing the hand - game-going hands - balanced hands.

Post-beginner and above

This page last revised 19th Dec 2019