M J Bridge
♦
♠
♥
♣
Responder root page
Bidding
M J Bridge
♦
♠
♥
♣
Responder root page
Bidding
Relays and negatives
Relay responses
By far the simplest method (albeit perhaps not the best) is ‘always relay’.
Quite simply you will make a waiting bid whatever your holding, and then take some suitable action once opener has told you his hand-
Usually this relay (waiting) bid will be the next suit up.
Beginner and above
♠
♥
♦
♣
Q J T 5 2
A 4
T 8 6
7 5 3
Partner opened 2♣ (artificial and strong).
Bid 2♦ (negative) if your positive response would promise 8 or more points.
Mix and match
Quite a common agreement in club play is to play two strong bids, 2♣ and 2♦. Typically, 2♣ will be a strong one-
It is perfectly possible to play relay responses in either case or ‘negatives and positives’ in either case.
A not uncommon agreement is to play relay responses facing the weaker of the two opening bids, but a ‘positive or negative’ response facing the stronger bid.
There is some logic to this approach, and you may choose to go along with it, particularly if that is what your partner is used to.
If you do choose to play different sets of responses facing each of the two opening bids then there is something to be said for adding 'weak twos in the majors' as an alternative to the relay when facing the weaker of the two openings.
However life is a whole lot simpler, particularly if playing with an occasional partner, if you stick to the same method in both situations.
And in any case, although I played 'Benji for many years at quite a high level, it is not my system of choice.
I prefer to play a form of ‘positive’ which is strong and game-
This page last revised 4th Nov 2026
Context -
Post-
‘Always relay’ is my recommended beginner method, and if you choose to stick with it it will serve you well to a high level.
Apart from anything else this leaves partner the maximum bidding space in which to show his hand.
(I should acknowledge here that this recommendation differs from both the 'Bridge for All' and the 'Standard English' approach in which any hand of 8 or more points, together with some other specific holdings, will make some sort of positive response.)
The only argument against the ‘always relay’ method is that it is a wasted opportunity.
Given that there is the opportunity to tell partner about some feature of the hand most partnerships will include some type (or types) of positive (or informative) response. It will then be necessary to redefine your bids for those hands which do not qualify for a ‘positive’ or 'informative' response.
I use the term 'informative' to cover agreed styles of response which do not promise some minimum stength. Examples are low point-count 'laddering' and 'natural weak two' responses.
Negative responses
If you agree always to make some form of positive or informative response whenever you hold some minimum agreed strength (say 8+ points as in standard English) then your 1-up response becomes a negative rather than a relay, denying as many as 8 points (or whatever your agreed minimum for a positive response might be).
Non-positive relays
If, on the other hand your non-relay responses are more specific and do not cover all stronger hands then your relay response will only deny the specific holding required for a positive response and may on occasion contain additional strength.
I call such bids 'non-positve relays'.
An example might be when your only positive responses promise a suit of at least 5 cards headed by 3 of the top 5 honours (say). Strong hands which do not satisfy this requirement would have to travel by way of a non-positive relay response.
♠
♥
♦
♣
Q J 9 5 2
A 4
K 8 6
7 5 3
Partner opened 2♣ (artificial and strong).
This is a strong hand facing partner's strong opening bid and may well be sufficient for a slam, but it does not contain a strong suit headed by the QJT or better.
Bid 2♦ -
Alternatives to 'the next suit up'.
In the old days when natural strong two-
Even within such a system most partnerships moved on to ‘Herbert negatives’ in which the negative response was the cheapest bid available -
The principle of ‘the next suit up’ has carried over into the world of artificial strong opening bids.
The use of 2NT as a negative over partner's strong 2♣ or 2♦ is all but unknown.
Any response other than 'the next suit up' will be either a ‘'positive response' or an 'informative response'’ promising some specific holding according to partnership agreement.
♠
♥
♦
♣
Q J T 5 2
A 4
K 8 6
7 5 3
Partner opened 2♣ (artificial and strong).
You have a most promising holding, but for the moment just bid 2♦ if your agreed method is ‘always relay’.
Remember, partner will bid again.
You will, of course, show signs of genuine excitement with your next bid.
| Opener |
| Overcaller |
| Responder |
| Advancer |
| Opener's rebid |
| Overcaller's rebid and beyond |
| Responder's rebid and beyond |
| The continuing auction |
| Opener |
| Overcaller |
| Responder |
| Advancer |
| Opener's rebid |
| Overcaller's rebid and beyond |
| Responder's rebid and beyond |
| The continuing auction |
| Opener |
| Overcaller |
| Responder |
| Advancer |
| Opener's rebid |
| Overcaller's rebid and beyond |
| Responder's rebid and beyond |
| The continuing auction |