M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Intermediate and above

No interference


Is partner’s opening bid forcing?


Your first decision relates to whether or not partner’s opening bid is forcing.

Certainly a pass can only be considered if 2♦ is bound to be the best contract.

Bearing in mind that partner might hold a balanced hand of twenty three or more points, or a six-card major, this only really leaves one freak hand on which you might even consider passing.

♠

♥

♦

♣

2


9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2

5 4 3 2

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

If pass is permitted in your system then this would be the hand to do it on - there isn’t even a potential entry into your hand in no trumps.


For me this hand is too freakish to expect even once in a lifetime of bridge, and so my suggestion is that the opening bid should be treated as forcing for one round.  Apart from anything else, partner will then feel a whole lot happier about opening his twenty six point balanced hand (or whatever your maximum holding might be) by this route.


I shall assume for the remainder of this page that partner’s weak options are single-suited (six cards) in either major.  If one of your options shows a two-suited hand it will make only the slightest difference at this point in the auction.  If partner’s suit might be five-card then the calculations might be different, but the line of thinking will be exactly the same.


The common ground


2♥ response


Your initial assumption must be that partner holds a weak two in one of the majors.

With nothing to justify either a preemptive raise or an invitational bid opposite such a holding you have little choice but to bid 2♥, happy for partner to pass if this is his suit or to convert to spades otherwise.


This will be by far your most common action.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 8

8 7

A K 7 3

Q 7 6 4 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

Bid 2♥.

Partner will usually pass or convert to 2♠ after which you will pass.


♠

♥

♦

♣

A K Q J 9 5 4

8

A 2

K Q 7 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

There is only one spot in which you wish to play on this hand.

Bid 4♠.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 9 8

8 7

A K 7 3

K Q 5 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

This hand must have game potential facing any variety of weak two.

Bid 2NT to learn more about partner’s hand.



The 2NT response


This is always played as artificial and forcing.

As you will see when we come to look at opener’s rebid, there will be sufficient bidding space available for opener to show his hand type if strong, and to show both his suit and whether he is maximum or minimum in the range if weak.


The question arises as to how strong you should be for this action.

The discussion below about invitational and preemptive raises is relevant to this decision.  If your 2NT bid includes the possibility of preemptive raises to the three-level then there will be no minimum strength requirement - just sufficient length in both majors.  If on the other hand the 2NT bid promises an invitational interest even when facing a weak two in a major then there should be some basic requirement in terms of high card strength.

However, it should be noted that trick taking potential is more important than point-count in this respect - one well placed top honour in partner’s suit might well convert his weak opening hand into six playing tricks.  A good starting point is ‘any hand of fifteen or more points’ for such action if you have hopes of making a game by brute force.  You should feel free to vary this limit.  It will depend in part on the range of your weak two.

It would be remiss of me not to point out that many excellent players will see the potential of a hand which is significantly weaker than this - even down to about eleven points.


The two bids outlined above are actually sufficient to allow you to get started with the multi, but it is unlikely that you will have included a convention such as the multi-2♦ without wishing to take on at least some of the further options.


Where methods differ


Invitational and preemptive


With a weak hand and three cards in a major facing partner’s six-card suit you would in general wish to compete to the three-level.

The difficulty lies in trying to cater for hands which are at least 3-3 in the majors as well as for those which have three cards in only one major, whilst still retaining the immediate preemptive effect of a natural weak two and whilst also still keeping a sufficient number of genuine invitational sequences available.  Compromises have to be made, and different partnerships will allocate the available sequences in slightly different ways.


The next two bids are describes as they are played by most, but not all, partnerships.


Invitational in spades


If you can see the possibility of a game when partner is weak in spades but not if he is weak in hearts, then start with 2♥ as above.

Chris Ryall calls such bids ‘paradox’ bids, when you bid the suit you don’t hold.

If partner passes you will be happy.

If partner corrects to 2♠ then you will raise invitationally to the three-level.  Partner can then choose between pass and 4♠.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 8 4

8 7 2

A K

Q 7 6 4 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

Bid 3♥.

Partner will usually pass or convert to 3♠ after which you will pass.



Similarly, a response of 3♠ would suggest a weak raise with three spades and four hearts.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 8 4

8 7 6 2

A K

Q 7 4 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

Bid 3♠.

Partner will usually pass or convert to 4♥ after which you will pass.



Clearly the allocations above can be reversed, and commonly are.


If you do choose to reverse the allocations then your 2NT response will include both weak and invitational possibilities.  Your opponents will not know anything about your strength at this point.  This makes it difficult for them to defend.


A common usage is that 3♥ is preemptive as above and 2NT sequences are invitational in principle but may be used psychically on the weaker hand.  This route can be particularly effective against partnerships which are not prepared for it.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 9 8

7

A K 7 3

K J 6 4 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

If partner holds a maximum weak two in spades then there must be the possibility of a game.

Bid 2♥.

If partner converts to 2♠ you will raise invitationally to three.


Invitational in hearts


If you can see the possibility of a game when partner is weak in hearts, but not if he is weak in spades then start with 2♠.

If partner passes you will be happy.

Your bid implies an invitational hand in hearts.  If partner’s opening was based on a weak two in hearts he can choose between 3♥ and 4♥.

♠

♥

♦

♣

7

A 9 8

A K 7 3

K Q 6 3 2

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

If partner holds a maximum weak two in hearts then game is likely.

Bid 2♠.

Partner can either pass or choose between 3♥ and 4♥.


The alternative is to play the two sequences above as preemptive, based solely on length.

In itself this is a good idea, but you will then have to take the hands above by way of 2NT.  If you make this choice you will find yourself playing at the three-level on a 6-1 fit just a little too often.


Preemptive with both majors


My choice is that an immediate response of 3♥ is a pass or correct bid on a hand which is at least 3-3 in the majors and with insufficient for game opposite one of partner’s weak options.


Invitational in either major


If you have adopted the allocation above then with the hand which has invitational values in either major you must start with a bid of 2NT.  Partner will respond according to the agreed scheme, after which you should be able to choose the final contract.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 7

A 8

A K 7 3

K Q J 6 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

If partner holds a maximum weak two then game is possible.

Bid 2NT.

You will then be able to choose the contract.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 8 4

8 7 2

A K

Q 7 6 4 3

Partner opens 2♦ (multi).

3♥ would be the normal preemptive offering.

But a bid of 2NT suggesting values followed by a return to 3♥ may well cause problems.



The problem of course is that your partner will also be in the dark, but usually this will not be important.


My choice is the one given first above, aiming for the maximum preemptive effect as quickly as possible, but the choice is yours - there is no clear winner on this one.  Be certain that you have agreed your version with your partner.


4♥ and 4♠


The preemptive approach above could be extended to higher-level bids, but responses of 4♥ and 4♠ are more commonly played as realistic natural game bids based on a long suit in responder’s hand.


Other strong responses


3♣, 3♦


These are usually played as natural and forcing.

What is not clear in any of the writings which I have seen is just exactly what length they offer - one source suggests a minimum of four cards in the suit, common sense suggests a longish and very solid suit.

I will suggest a high-quality suit of at least five cards, but I am ready to be swayed by the voices of greater expertise and experience.


3NT


Sometimes played as natural, but this feels a bit like a waste of a bid to me - you can always start with 2NT.

The alternative is to play it as artificial and forcing along with the next two bids.


4♣, 4♦


These are usually played as artificial and forcing.

For me they go a step beyond any level of complexity which I would normally consider incorporating, but Chris Ryall has constructive suggestions on his web-site.

Opener’s first bid

Opener’s rebid

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder - partner opened a multi 2♦.