M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Beginner only

No intervention


It should be noted that this page is included with a degree of reluctance.


Natural strong twos were the norm for many years, but their day has passed and they are rarely encountered in club or tournament play.

There is something to be said for including them as a first step in the learning process but even that argument is far from overwhelming. You should aim to move on sooner rather than later.


In the following I include a number of refinements, but if you are using this method as a learning stage then it will be sufficient to concentrate on the basics.  A negative (or non-positive) bid and some definition of a positive response to justify an immediate raise of partner’s suit will be quite enough for the moment.

If you are ready to take anything else on board then you are ready to expand your methods in other ways.


Partner has opened two of any suit.  Clubs may or may not be included in this choice depending on partnership methods.

He has a strong hand (rule for strong openings) worth eight and a half playing tricks (or thereabouts according to the partnership agreement), he should have either a decent six-card suit or two decent five-card suits, his bid is forcing for one round, and he promises a further bid.


I shall come to the matter of positive responses below, but first let me look briefly at the negative responses.  It might sound a little obvious, but a ‘negative’ response should be made on any hand which does not qualify for a ‘positive’ response - i.e. it does not have to be a complete ‘bust’.


Note that there is no need for a relay response in this style - it only exists in artificial methods to give opener the opportunity to show his hand.


Negative responses


2NT negative


Traditionally the negative response was 2NT.

♠

♥

♦

♣

T 9 8

8 7 4

7 3

7 6 5 4 3

Partner opened 2♦.

This hand is not worth a positive response by any standard.

Bid 2NT if that is your negative.


There is an immediate weakness in this method.  Over opening bids other than 2♠ it is wasteful of bidding space.  Even your negative response takes you immediately to the three-level.

Usually you will reach this point anyway, but if, as an extreme example, partner is two-suited with six diamonds, five spades, and no more than eight and a half playing tricks, he will not be particularly appreciative of your negative efforts.


Better is to play


Herbert negatives


Quite simply the negative response is the next suit up (and 2NT over 2♠), so, for example, if partner opens 2♥ then the negative response will be 2♠.

♠

♥

♦

♣

T 9 8

8 7 4

7 3

7 6 5 4 3

Partner opened 2♦.

This hand does not warrant a positive response by any standard.

Bid 2♥ if you have agreed to play Herbert negatives.


Positive responses


Any response other than the agreed negative is a positive and will promise some specified feature or features in the hand.

Thus any immediate raise of partner’s suit is a positive response, as is any bid in a new suit (other than the suit being used as a Herbert negative - if you play Herbert negatives then a bid of 2NT is equivalent to a positive in the Herbert negative suit.)

Any positive response creates a game-forcing situation.


The requirements for a positive response vary from partnership to partnership, and may vary depending on the level at which the bid is made and whether the bid is in partner’s suit or a new suit.

Some play a positive defined by a points holding - eight say.  Others prefer to specify a specific holding in top honours.

In either case the holding should have the potential to yield at least one and a half playing tricks to put alongside partner’s minimum of eight and a half as you force to game.


I shall suggest an arbitrary general rule for a positive, and that is that you should hold at least eight points, or an ace and a king, before making any positive response, but you may well have further requirements.  (Note that this is no more than a simple rule of thumb, and does not relate in any way to the methods which I shall recommend as we adopt alternative systems.)


Suit support


Three-card support is sufficient to justify raising partner’s suit (he may hold just a five-card suit in a two-suited hand).


As both a raise to the three-level and a raise to game are game-forcing it is clearly desirable to distinguish between them.

The traditional method was that a raise to four denied an ace.

The raise to three therefore promised at least one ace, and paved the way for a subsequent slam investigation.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 8

Q 7 4

7 3

A 6 5 4 3

Partner opens 2♥.

Three-card support and nine good points.

Bid 3♥, showing a positive raise with at least one ace.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 5

K 7 4

7 3

K Q 5 4 3

Partner opens 2♥.

You have three-card support and a lot of points, but you do not have the top honours to justify a slam-try.

Bid 4♥ showing a positive but denying as much as an ace.

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 8 3

Q 7 4

7 3

A 6 5 4 3

Partner opens 2♥.

Three-card support, an ace, and some points, but this hand does not qualify for a positive response.

Bid 2♠ (Herbert negative).

You may well bid 4♥ on your next bid.


New suit


First of all, your priority should be to show support for partner’s suit even if you hold a good side-suit of your own.

Any positive response in a new suit will therefore deny as much as three-card support.

I shall retain my arbitrary definition of a positive response as given above, but there is a further requirement.  In general partner will have little interest in your suit - he will have one or two suits of his own, and in the first place they will be his choice(s) for where to play.  Remember, if your suit is of high quality it should make tricks anyway, and if it is anything less than high quality it is likely to be irrelevant.

Therefore, only change suit if it offers a realistic source of tricks.  I shall suggest a minimum of a five-card suit containing three of the top five honours, but you may choose to vary this a little as a partnership.

In the absence of such a holding you may be forced to make a negative response even with a good points holding - remember, partner will bid again.  (Technically such a bid would be a ‘non-positive’ as opposed to a negative.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 5

K 4

K Q 3

7 6 5 4 3

Partner opens 2♥.

Good points but less than three hearts, and a side suit to be ashamed of.

Bid 2♠ (Herbert negative).

On your next bid you will go to game, either in partner’s six-card heart suit, or in his second suit.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 5

K 4

7 6 3

K Q 5 4 3

Partner opens 2♥.

Good points but less than three hearts.  For me the club suit is not quite up to standard.

I bid 2♠ (Herbert negative), but some partnerships will find a 3♣ positive.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 6 5

K 4

7 6 3

K Q J 4 3

Partner opens 2♥.

Good points but less than three hearts.

The club suit is well up to standard and promises a realistic source of tricks.

Bid 3♣.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q J 4 3

K 4

7 6 3

Q 6 5

Partner opens 2♥.

Good points but less than three hearts.

The spade suit is well up to standard and promises a realistic source of tricks.

Bid 2NT showing a positive response in the ‘Herbert negative’ suit - spades.


Jump in a new suit


There is just one extremely rare situation in which you might insist on playing in your own suit, and that is when you hold a self-supporting suit of your own.

By self-supporting I mean that it may be expected to play for no losers even opposite a void in partner’s hand.

In effect this means a minimum of A K Q x x x x, or A K Q J x x.


With such a hand you may make an immediate response of a jump in a new suit.

Even then you might finish up playing in partner’s suit, but at least you have told him  that you can provide at least six tricks to the cause.

Opener’s first bid

Opener’s rebid

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K Q J 4 3

4

7 6 3

K Q 6 5

Partner opens 2♥.

You would certainly hope for a slam on this hand - it will probably depend on partner’s holding in diamonds.

But first tell partner about the nature and quality of your hand with a jump to 3♠.

This page last revised 22nd Apr 2018

Context  -  Responder’s first bid - partner opened a natural and forcing strong two.