M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Gerber


It is with considerable misgivings that I include this convention (see below).


Playing the Gerber convention a response of 4♣ to an opening bid of 2NT asks opener to show how many aces he holds.


The usual scale of responses is:-


4♦ shows 0 or 4;

4♥ shows 1;

4♠ shows 2;

and 4NT shows 3.

♠

♥

♦

♣

6

9 2

T 8 5

A K Q 8 5 3 2

Partner opened 2NT.

Bid 4♣, if Gerber is your chosen approach (but see below).

Provided that partner shows three aces you will follow with either 6♣ or 6NT.


As shown in the example it may appear to be the only route available to a slam on a hand based on a long suit.

On the other hand, in the example above you will be none the wiser if partner shows anything other than three aces, even though he may well stop the fourth suit with the KQ.

There is much to be said for just bidding some number of no trumps with a small prayer, whilst giving nothing away.


This convention will be part of the armoury of the majority of players in clubs throughout the length and breadth of the country.  That may in itself be sufficient reason for you adopt this simple convention.


But


even with this bid in your armoury it should not be your first thought as you begin the search for a slam.


There is much more to a slam than the number of aces.

It is indeed important to know when bidding a slam that there are not two aces missing and therefore two immediate losers, and the Gerber convention addresses that particular potential problem admirably.


But before you investigate immediate losers you should be certain that there are sufficient tricks in the hand to justify the search for a slam.  Remember, it is perfectly possible to hold all four aces and make just four tricks - not perhaps when partner has opened 2NT but the point is still apposite.


So your first step should normally be to ascertain that the two hands between them have the potential to produce twelve or thirteen tricks, and if the answer is ‘yes’ then you might wish to check that there are not two immediate losers.


With hopes of a slam your first thought should usually be to find out more about the two hands.


With a balanced hand a quantitative raise is far superior to an ace-asking convention, taking into account those minor honours which might add solidity to a suit.

With an unbalanced hand:-

there might be a suit fit with the potential to produce an extra ruffing trick;

you might just want to tell partner that you have some slam interest if his hand is totally suitable.


Following such an investigation you might choose to ask about aces, but it will be an extremely rare hand on which that will be your best initial response.


Furthermore there are other uses for the immediate response of 4♣, and you will almost certainly wish to assign a related meaning to 4♦ at the same time.

Easiest is to use these bids as natural slam-tries based on single-suited hands, which I include in improvers’ methods.

Other possibilities will be discussed as we come on to intermediate methods.


So, by all means, include Gerber to keep your partner happy, but, whenever an occasion rises when you think you might use it as an initial response, just ask yourself first if there isn’t a better alternative route available.

Opener’s first bid

Opener’s rebid

Beginner and above

This page last revised 1st May 2019

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s first bid - partner opened 2NT (strong) - a beginning method.