M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

New suit at the lowest level

Opener’s first bid

Opener’s rebid

Beginner only

Context  -  Responder’s first bid - partner opened one minor - opponents doubled - change of suit responses.

Not recommended

The negative free bid


Traditionally the immediate lowest-level response in a new suit was redefined over the opponents’ double.

The bid was used as a weak escape - natural and not forcing.  Such a bid is called a ‘negative free bid’.


Negative free bids were also played following a suit overcall.

In that situation I have no time for the bid - the hand is still quite likely to belong to your side, and some of your bidding space has been taken away - you need to retain as many constructive sequences as possible.

And the most basic constructive sequences start with a natural forcing change of suit response.


BUT……..


RHO has suggested something of a holding in each of the other suits.  You therefore introduce a new suit at your peril.

Your change of suit should promise either extra length (at least five cards) or excellent quality (or both).  With anything less than this, and a poor fit for partner at best, you will usually do better by defending the hand and pass will be the recommended action.  If your hand is too strong for such action then redouble will usually be a better choice.


I will though recommend that some jump responses be played as obstructive - i.e. weak and non-forcing (jump in a new suit).

Question

My guideline

If the opponents double and I respond with a simple change of suit, is it forcing?

Yes.

There is rather more point when following an opponent’s double, particularly against pairs whose double promises at the very least a ‘good’ opening bid.  It is less likely that there will be a significant contract your way, no bidding space has been taken away, and you have an immediate opportunity to tell partner about the nature of your weak holding whilst putting something of an obstruction in the way of the opponents.


However, it is still not my choice - there is room for the constructive option of a simple forcing change of suit.

Beginner and above

This page last revised 16th Dec 2018