M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Opener’s first bid

Walsh


This can be a difficult topic to research and discuss because there is more than one ‘Walsh’ convention.  The different conventions apply at different points in the auction, and each has its own variations.  The nomenclature tends not to distinguish clearly as to which variation is currently under discussion, and the confusion can be compounded by the fact that the various conventions which carry this name have been introduced either jointly or independently by a husband and wife team (later divorced).


What follows is my interpretation of my research into the matter.  I cannot vouch that I have necessarily reached all the correct conclusions, but this should not detract from the general gist of the method currently under discussion.


‘Walsh’ most commonly refers to a system of responses to partner’s opening bid of 1♣ - that is the subject of this page.


This treatment was part of the Walsh system - developed by Richard and Rhoda Walsh - a system which has since morphed into the ‘two over one game forcing system’.

It is played mostly by partnerships which have adopted a system based around five-card majors and a short club - clearly a 1♣ opening bid will occur more frequently in such a system.


For those who require a more all-embracing and far more authoritative treatment of the subject I can do no better than refer you to Rhoda Walsh’s pages on the Neapolitan club site.


Meanwhile my particular focus of attention lies in the question of whether to respond 1♦ or 1 major with a holding in both suits.


The following is more or less the basic form of the Walsh method as I understand it:-


with less than game-going values in a hand containing at least one four-card major your first response will normally be in the major, even when you hold four or five diamonds;


with a game-going hand containing one or more four-card majors, and at least two diamonds, your first response will normally be 1♦ - artificial, and forcing for one round in the first instance;


if you subsequently rebid in a major then the auction becomes game-forcing at a delightfully low level.


if you subsequently pass or rebid in anything other than a major then you are showing a weak hand - some versions use immediate responses of 1♦, 1NT and 2NT to further define the range of such hands.


Clearly this approach is at odds with the Acol approach of bidding four-card suits ‘up the line’.

I shall not suggest a wholesale change to your methods, but there might be some hands on which there is an argument for bidding the four-card major before a four-card diamond suit.

Post intermediate and above

This page last revised 24th Sep 2020

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s first bid - partner opened one minor in first or second seat - no intervention - moving forward.