M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Smolen


The defining feature of Smolen is that a Stayman 2♣ bid followed by a jump to three of a major if a fit is not immediately forthcoming is game-forcing with four cards in the bid major and five cards in the other major.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A Q 8 6

K Q 8 7 3

T 2

K 5

Partner opened 1NT.

You have 4-5 in the majors together with game-going values.

Playing Smolen start with a Stayman 2♣ enquiry.

If partner responds 2♦ you will rebid 3♠ - game-forcing and promising five hearts.

Intermediate and above

Opener’s first bid

Partner opened 1NT.

You are 5-4 in the majors with invitational values.

Bid 2♣, intending to follow a 2♦ response with 2♠ promising five spades and another unspecified four-card suit in an unbalanced hand with invitational values.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A Q T 8 6

K Q 8 3

T 9 2

5

Opener’s rebid

Context  -  Partner opened 1NT - RHO passed - intermediate and beyond - underlying methods.

This page last revised 12th Apr 2020


You will need to agree a number of other conventions alongside this to describe a variety of different hand-types.

There is considerable latitude in how you do this.


The following is no more than one possible selection of such agreements.


They work quite well together, tending a little towards the ‘conventions heavy’ end of the spectrum.  They add up to a coherent method, but they are by no means prescriptive.


A selection such as this is not atypical of what is played in the best circles, but it does not begin to be a ‘standard’ - you will meet all sorts of variations out there in the tournament world.


Numerous possibilities will be found in the section


variations and extensions


Unbalanced invitational hands with a five-card major


A common extension is to take on board two otherwise redundant sequences.


1NT, 2♣, 2x, 2♠    invitational with five spades and another four-card suit;

1NT, 2♦, 2♥, 2♠    invitational with five hearts and another four-card suit.


Note that the four-card suit may or may not be the other major.


Note also that you will need to adopt the ‘4-4 in the majors’ version of garbage Stayman to release one of the sequences above.


Alternatively it is perfectly possible to dispense with these two sequences and take all invitational hands through a 2NT rebid as in ‘variations on an improver’s method’.


Transfer breaks


A system of transfer breaks over a red suit transfer is strongly recommended.

In the straightforward method included here opener jumps to three of the major with four-card support and a minimum and bids 2NT with four-card support in a stronger hand - simple yet effective, and it gives little away.


Strongly recommended are two-tier transfers into the minors.


To show the invitational balanced raise you will need to adopt non-promissory Stayman or something similar.


Not everyone’s choice, but I am a great fan of South African Texas transfers to show a hand single-suited in a major with at least a slam interest unless you can incorporate some other way of showing such hands at a lower level (see Allerton and Jagger).


5-5 in the majors


Straightforward and effective is to modify a treatment from Allerton and Jagger.

Start with 2♣ (non-promissory Stayman).

If partner responds in a major you can pass, raise invitationally, raise to game, or bid a new suit at the three-level (choose your level of complexity - either go the full ‘Allerton and Jagger’ or just bid the other major at the three-level) to agree the suit and show a slam interest).

If partner responds 2♦ then rebid 2♥ with a weak take-out, 3♦ to show an invitational hand with 5-5 in the majors, or 3♣ to show a game-going or stronger hand with 5-5 in the majors.


Five-card major and four-card minor


Game-going hands with a five-card major and a four-card minor can be readily shown with a transfer into the major followed by a natural and forcing rebid in the minor.


Stayman and new suit


In the present implementation I have included control-showing cue-bids to agree partner’s suit and show at least a modicum of slam interest, or to show some type of 5-5 holding in the majors when partner can do no better than 2♦.

However, these methods are replaceable.  Other options are indicated on the pages Stayman and new suit.


Three-level responses


This leaves immediate responses at the three-level available for some other purpose.


The following simplified version based on minors and shortages is straightforward and effective on most hands.


My choice is to use the immediate responses of three of a suit to show minor suit orientated game-going or better hands with a shortage and thus potentially unsuitable for a no trump contract.

A  simple assignment is:-


3♣     short clubs, at least four diamonds, may contain four hearts and/or four spades

3♦     short diamonds, at least four clubs, may contain four hearts and/or four spades

3♥     short hearts, at least 4-4 in the minors, may contain four spades

3♠     short spades, at least 4-4 in the minors


Alternatively interchange with almost any other system of three-level responses such as that included under ‘variations on an improver’s method’.

Variations are discussed briefly on the page minors and shortages.


Evaluation


I have little choice but to commend this convention to you, as it is a widely (quite possibly the most widely) used method at a good club level.


However, my understanding is that Smolen appeared on the scene before transfer responses to 1NT became commonplace.

I cannot believe that had the order been reversed then the hand with five hearts and four spades would not have been introduced with a 2♣ enquiry followed by a 3♦ transfer to show five hearts and four spades.

This is a more efficient use of bidding space and it is more intuitive.

It takes away the sequence 1NT, 2♣, 2♦, 3♦ but in return it releases the sequence 1NT, 2♣, 2♦, 3♠ for some other purpose.


But basically I don’t believe that there is anything to choose between ‘variations on an improver’s method’, Smolen, and a Smolen/Quest hybrid, provided that you have thought through how you are going to deal with all the various hand-types.


Just choose your underlying method and your add-ons (particularly in respect of immediate responses at the three-level and invitational unbalanced hands with a five-card major) and you will be well set - unless of course you wish to take on an expert method such as Allerton and Jagger.