M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Shortcomings using improvers’ methods


The example hands on the previous page give some indication of the power and versatility which these methods are able to deliver.


The eagle-eyed will though have noticed that a few sequences were not used, and a few hand-types were bypassed.

Some of these require no more than a little further definition.

Others require a more advanced set of agreements.

There are many possibilities, the main ones being considered under ‘intermediate and beyond’.


However, I cannot overemphasise that these improvers’ methods will serve you well up to and well-beyond a good standard.


Locating opener’s five-card major


If you have agreed to open 5-3-3-2 hands containing a five-card major with 1NT when in the range then the methods given so far will sometimes leave you unable to locate a superior 5-3 fit in opener’s major, particularly at the part-score level.


One solution is simply to play a version of five-card Stayman.


But note that there are both positives and negatives in playing five-card Stayman when facing a 1NT opener, and it is far from universal in the expert world.

Note in particular that on game-going hands you will frequently be able to locate the 5-3 major suit fit even when playing four-card Stayman.


There are a number of variations of five-card Stayman from which to choose - but be warned, you will have to adjust a few other agreements at the same time.  The pros and cons along with the necessary mechanisms, are discussed and linked from the page five-card Stayman.


Setting the suit for a slam-try


There is a significant difference between typical club methods and expert methods when responder wishes to investigate a slam. Typically at club level responder will transfer into the major and then bid 4NT as RKCB with the assumption that the suit has been set. This is a dangerous assumption on what may well be no better than a 5-2 fit.


Expert practice is to treat the jump rebid to 4NT following a transfer as a limit raise, just as an immediate jump to 4NT would have been. With a minimum hand opener will pass with two cards in the major, or bid five of the major with three-card support.  With a maximum he will choose between six of the major and 6NT.


The expert approach is strongly recommended.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q J 8 6

A J

K Q 6 4

A 8

Partner opened 1NT.

Bid 2♥.

Rebid 4NT (quantitative) over partner’s 2♠ response or force with a natural 3♦.


This leaves us with the problem of what to do when you hold a six-card suit as responder and wish to set the trump suit before embarking on a search for key-cards.


If you have adopted the slam-try approach to an immediate response at the three-level then the problem disappears.


If on the other hand you have adopted any other uses for these bids then an alternative method will be required.  One such alternative solution is to incorporate a convention such as ‘South African Texas transfers’.  It is a simple add-on which does not affect other parts of your system.  Feel free to incorporate it at any stage.


Five-four or five-five in the majors


The most significant shortcoming of improvers’ methods is the inability to distinguish between game-try, game-going, slam-try, and slam-going hands with the above shapes.

In particular, these improvers’ methods deal extremely well with both invitational and game-going hands which are 5-4 in the majors, and they also cope with a game-going hand which is 5-5 in the majors, but with other strengths of 5-5 shape or with 5-4 shape and worth a slam-try they leave much to be desired.


There are many methods from which to choose to help deal with this situation.


Much of the section on ‘intermediate and beyond’ exists to provide a solution to this problem.


Whichever combination of advanced methods you choose will lead to complications, a myriad of extended sequences, and a load of memory work.  Meanwhile the intermediate methods to be found in the present section will serve you well on the vast majority of deals at anything less than expert level.

Post-beginner and above

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s first bid - partner opened 1NT - RHO passed - improvers’ methods.

This page last revised 20th Mar 2020