M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Shortcomings in the beginning method


The beginners’ methods considered so far are excellent as a learning method, but they have a number of serious shortcomings.

These are summarised below.


Invitational hands


If responder has a balanced hand then an invitational raise of 2NT on eleven or twelve points is ideal.

But, if his hand is unbalanced he has only weak and game-forcing options available.  There is no facility to show his shape and to invite at the same time.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q 8 2

K Q 6 3

J 8 4 3

J

Partner opened 1NT.

4-4-4-1 shape - and a poor twelve points.

Too good for a weak take-out, neither strong enough nor the right shape to force to game with 3♠, and far from an ideal shape for an invitational 2NT.


This problem will be addressed when we look at the Stayman convention in the next section.


Responder has a shapely hand


Sometimes there is clearly sufficient for game, but the best strain is far from clear.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q J 6 2

4

Q J 8 4 3

A 7

Partner opened 1NT.

There should be a game available, but is it 3NT, 4♠ or 5♦?

You can only offer a choice between spades and no trumps.


This problem is easily addressed by adopting a system of transfer responses.

These will appear in the next section.  You should look to incorporate these into your methods at an early stage.


Is there a better contract with a 4-4 major-suit fit?


Four of a major based on a 4-4 major-suit fit is usually a sounder contract than 3NT.

In general it will generate an extra trick, and it will also guard against the possible existence of a weak suit.

We have a method to search for a fit when holding a five-card suit, but not when holding just four cards in the suit.

♠

♥

♦

♣

K Q 6 2

8 4

Q J 8

A J 9 7

Partner opened 1NT.

There should be a game available, but is 3NT safe - there could be a fatal weakness in hearts?

Might there be a better contract in spades?


Once again, the Stayman convention which we shall meet in the next section, will get round this dilemma.


Is the right player declarer?


With weak take-outs it is responder with the weaker hand who will be declaring the contract.  Opener who holds the majority of the partnership points must lay his hand on the table for all to see.

Wouldn’t it be better if opener were declaring the hand, with his holding hidden from the opposition and with the opening lead coming towards his high cards?

♠

♥

♦

♣

9 7 4

8 7 6 5 3 2

5 2

8 4

Partner opened 1NT.

Something of an extreme example, but you want to play in hearts, and you would much prefer partner to be declarer.

Playing weak take-outs you will be declarer.

Beginner only

This page last revised 21st Mar 2018

Context  -  Acol bidding - responder’s first bid - partner opened 1NT - RHO passed - a beginning method.


This time transfer responses, as introduced in the next section, will remove the difficulty in a simple and logical manner.

Opener’s first bid

Opener’s rebid