M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Opener’s first bid

This page last revised 29th Aug 2021

Opener’s rebid

Context  -  Responder - partner opened 1NT - RHO doubled (natural).

Intermediate and above

Overview


The opponents’ double has changed everything.

There will be some hands on which you would have passed, but on which you now want to cash in because you know you hold the balance of points, and there will be other hands on which you might have passed even though you knew the contract was failing, but on which you now need to find a hopefully cheaper escape.

♠

♥

♦

♣

8 7 6 2

T 8 3

Q 8 7 4

6 5

Partner opened 1NT and RHO doubled.

This could be expensive - particularly if vulnerable.

You would really like a method to find a way out of the mess.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 7 6 2

T 8 3

Q 8 7 4

K 6

Partner opened 1NT and RHO doubled.

You would have passed partner’s 1NT in the uncontested auction, but now there is the possibility of making game in 1NTxx.

It would be a wasted opportunity not to do anything.


The first point to note is that the methods discussed on these pages apply when the double comes in the immediate overcall position.


A number of authorities suggest that they apply equally when the double comes in the protective seat.  This certainly leads to the simple life, but the situation is different.  Alternative possibilities are discussed under responder’s rebid.


The conventional methods are, in general, a good thing, but they are not quite as essential as some would have you believe.

My regular partner and I played for many years in quite good company with no more than a basic natural agreement.  Those dreaded scores of -800, so feared by the proponents of a strong no trump and particularly in teams play, just didn’t happen (well hardly ever).


It is worth remembering that such disasters are rare enough to be all but inconsequential at pairs scoring - the odd ‘bottom’ is neither here nor there, and at teams scoring it is only when you go for 800 or more and your opponents can score little better than a non-vulnerable game that the occurrence will prove seriously expensive.  Just don’t open on a hollow twelve point hand when vulnerable, and do have some common sense understandings in place - you won’t go far wrong.


Having said that, most serious partnerships have some sort of ‘wriggle’ available in this situation.


Methods and conventions


There are numerous methods available - David Stevenson outlines four pages of them on his site, and even that site doesn’t include the (not that uncommon) ‘Houdini’ convention by that name.


Similarly, Jeff Lang on the Bridgebum site discusses a selection of 11 of the more common ones (go to any one of them and you will find links to a further 10).


On this site I consider 10 methods, not all of which are recognized as standard conventional methods.


Aims


There are a number of possible aims to associate with your bids.

It is up to you to choose how to prioritise these aims, and it is this prioritisation along with your choice of the required degree of complication, which will direct your choice of method or convention.


1.  to find a relatively cheap escape on a weak hand.

For the present purposes a weak hand will include all hands of 0 to 5 points and may well extend to hands of 6 or 7 points.  On all of these your side is likely to hold less than half the points in the pack.

The escape will consist of a suit contract at the two-level on at least a 7-card fit based either on a suit of 5+ cards in your hand (and therefore at least a 5-2 fit) or 4 cards in your hand and at least a 4-3 fit between.


2.  to punish the opponents when the deal belongs to your side.

Typically this will be on hands of 8 or more points.

If your hand is reasonably balanced the most lucrative punishment will usually be to play the contract in 1NTxx with the prospect of making a cheap game contract, followed by the prospect of a penalty double facing any escape attempt on their part.


3. to make a game contract or higher your way.  As a general rule this will only score better than the doubled/redoubled contracts discussed in 2 above when your hand is extremely unbalanced and you are vulnerable against not.


4.  to preempt your opponents as they seek the best contract their way.


In general aim 1 is given the highest priority with aim 2 not far behind.  The method will be defined by how it addresses these aims.

Aim 3 tends to feature only rarely, particularly facing a weak no trump, but the generic approaches discussed under higher-level bids can be grafted on to most of the methods under discussion.


Aim 4 is in general not an aim in its own right, but it might affect the detail of your method in achieving aim 1.


Hand types


Concentrating on aim 1 and the weak hands there are four single-suited hand shapes (at least a five-card suit), six two-suited hand shapes (4-4) and and four 4-3-3-3 hand shapes - 14 in all.


Available sequences


To cope with these we have, at a first glance, 6 possible bids (pass, redouble, and two of a suit) which will not take us beyond the two-level as we search for a playable escape.


Setting aside pass and redouble for the moment, that leaves 2♣, 2♦, 2♥ and 2♠ - four bids to find an escape into one of the four suits - sounds reasonable if you don’t think about it doesn’t it?  However, if you use these bids to promise a five-card suit then you will find at least a 5-2 fit, but there will be no bids left with which to search for a 4-4 or a 4-3 fit - you cannot risk just bidding the suit and finding yourself in a 4-2 fit.  Alternatively you can increase your versatility by playing each of 2♣/2♦/2♥ to promise 4-4 shape in that suit and a higher-ranking suit. This certainly covers all of the 4-4 hands and leaves 2♠ available for a weak escape on a a five-card spade suit, but there are still three single-suited hands not accounted for, the distribution of the load on the three cheapest suit bids is, to say the least, extremely uneven, and there will be no built-in facility for the 4-3-3-3 hands.


The solution is to create additional sequences by introducing at least one artificial and forcing bid.

The artificial bid(s) will be one or both of pass and redouble.

In principle each of these produces five new sequences (you might pass on your rebid) for the loss of one natural bid, and in the case of a pass forcing to redouble the redoubled contract need not be lost.  However, the first artificial sequence followed by 2♠ will not produce a new way of showing a weak hand (there is only one such hand to show) and the second artificial sequence followed by 2♥ will not produce a further way of showing a weak hand (there are only two such hands to show).


And so, potentially you can create 11 sequences to show the 14 weak hands indicated above.


Note that bids of 2NT or higher have no purpose in the pursuit of aim 1.

In particular, any hand which is suitable for a natural and invitational bid of 2NT should always score better in either 1NTx or 1NTxx.


The 4-3-3-3 hands are relatively rare and in any case will frequently be best left in 1NTx (if you have that option available) at the top of the range.  It is common practice either not to cater for them directly but to muddle through as best as possible or to allocate just 1 sequence to cover the four possibilities.


The various methods available differ only in the choice and allocation of the available bids to achieve the prioritised aims.


Pass might be any one of:-


non-forcing;

forcing partner to redouble;

forcing partner to bid 2♣.


Pass is non-forcing  There are more than a few excellent players who will argue passionately that pass in this situation should be non-forcing  (See for example the discussion forum on BBO),

and if you play pass as non-forcing then the only way to reach a contract of 1NTxx will be to play xx as natural as well.


Certainly 1NTx will not infrequently be the best of a bad job - this is likely to be on a 4-4-3-2 or 4-3-3-3 hands of about 6 or 7 points - and with a stronger holding 1NTx is far more likely to be left in for a potentially good score than is 1NTxx which will usually be pulled.  It will however be more difficult for partner to find the penalty double if the opponents attempt an escape.  You will also find yourself with just 4 bids to cover all the weak escape options, although playing 2♣ as artificial and forcing goes some way to overcoming the problem.


More commonly xx will be played as some kind of puppet, thereby sacrificing the possibility of playing in 1NTxx but creating sufficient sequences to show all of the weak escapes.


In the methods discussed on this site the common-sense approach in its simplest form includes a non-forcing pass and a natural redouble,

and Allerton and Jagger includes a non-forcing pass together with xx as a puppet to 2♣.


Pass is puppet to xx a subsequent pass by you will allow you to show some strength and enable the possibility of a final contract of 1NTxx or a subsequent penalty double.

Alternatively,a subsequent suit bid will show some 4-4 combination of 2 suits.

This will frequently be played alongside a redouble puppet to 2♣ with any five-card suit in a weak hand,

and two of a suit to show the remaining 4-4 combinations.


In the methods discussed on this site the extended version of the common-sense approach and a basic wriggle each use this approach, Helvic uses the puppet to xx but spreads the load of the two-suited hands rather more evenly,  Houdini is similar but brings in the preemptive power of the spade suit rather more immediately, Halmic is similar but includes a specific sequence to deal with the 4-3-3-3 hand, and SWINE too plays pass as a puppet to xx and redouble as a puppet to 2♣ with a slightly different take on subsequent bids of two of a suit.


Pass is puppet to 2♣ in this method a pass will show one of a five-card suit in a weak hand or 4-4 shape with four clubs and another suit.


This usage does not feature in any of the methods considered on this site.


Redouble might be any one of:-


natural (to play);

puppet to 2♣;

transfer to clubs,


Redouble is natural  Certainly a good way to show your values quickly when holding (say) 8 or more points, but it sacrifices the opportunity to create additional sequences.


In the methods discussed on this site only the common sense approach, Houdini, and club standard use redouble in this way.


Redouble is puppet to 2♣. This is a common usage, rapidly creating additional sequences with which to describe a greater variety of hand-shapes.  If you play pass as a puppet to xx then you will still be able to show values and keep open the possibility of 1NTxx.


It will usually be played in one of two ways:-

i) on a five-card suit in a weak hand.  You will either pass 2♣ or correct to your five-card suit;

ii) with 4 clubs and some other 4-card suit (which may or may not be specified) in a weak hand.


In the methods discussed on this site a basic wriggle, Halmic, Helvic, and SWINE each use the redouble to promise a five-card suit;

Houdini promises clubs and another (not spades);

and Allerton and Jagger offer an interesting hybrid of single-suited in clubs or 2-suited without clubs.


Redouble is transfer to clubs. Note the difference from puppet - transfer implies a holding of 5 or more clubs - puppet makes no such promise.


This will be part of a transfer system.

There may be variations in detail, but basically we are discussing the method exit transfers.


A lowest level bid in a new suit might be any one of:-


natural weak five-card suit;

the lower of two four-card suits (possibly more closely defined);

any 4-3-3-3 hand;

a transfer.


natural weak five-card suit  This is self-explanatory;

lower of two four-card suits   e.g. bid suit and another or bid suit and spade;

any 4-3-3-3 hand              This is most likely to be 2♣ and will probably be played alongside some other possibility such as clubs and another;

transfer                       most probably 2♣, 2♦ and 2♥ but not 2♠ (see redouble).  This will be part of a system of exit transfers.


In the methods discussed on this site the common-sense approach, Houdini, and Allerton and Jagger each use the lowest-level bid in a new suit as as natural on a five-card suit in a weak hand (except for the 2♣ bid in Allerton and Jagger);

club standard, a basic wriggle, Halmic, Helvic, each use the bid in the new suit as some combination of two suits, and SWINE also uses 2♣ and 2♦ in this way but gives slightly more constructive meanings to 2♥ and 2♠.


As a particularly brief summary:-


The common-sense approach redouble shows values - pass is forcing to redouble, will serve you well up to quite a good standard, but it throws a heavy load on the pass and S.O.S redouble route when showing 4-4 shape;


Club standard also plays redouble as showing values - it is almost a reverse allocation from the common-sense approach, and also throws a heavy load on the sequences available to show 4-4 shape;


a basic wriggle  is similar to the common-sense approach and club standard, but plays redouble as forcing to 2♣;


Halmic pass is forcing to redouble, redouble is forcing to 2♣, and one sequence is allocated to cover all the 4-3-3-3 hands;


Helvic pass is forcing to redouble, redouble is forcing to 2♣, there are no sequences specifically allocated to 4-3-3-3 hands, but the 4-4 hands each have a specific sequence allocated;


Houdini  pass is forcing to redouble, redouble is forcing to 2♣, suits at the two-level are natural and weak, and an early emphasis is placed on whether or not the spade suit is held;


SWINE  pass is forcing to redouble, redouble is forcing to 2♣, and 2♥ and 2♠ are used slightly more constructively than in other methods;


Exit transfers use three of the available sequences (along with redouble) to show five-card suits.  That leaves just three sequences to cover the ten hand-shapes under consideration.


Allerton and Jagger concentrates almost totally on the weak escape and plays pass as non-forcing.


Evaluation


The common sense approach achieves what it sets out to do - and depending on your level of bridge might well prove more than adequate for your needs.


The basic wriggle also achieves what it sets out to do, but it wastes a number of sequences, which is why you will probably choose to move on to either Halmic or Helvic.


Exit transfers have the advantages of placing the declarer play in the stronger handing and providing the possibility of constructive sequences by way of a transfer followed by a new suit, but they are less efficient when it comes to finding a low-level escape on a weak hand.  I am not convinced that exit transfers are the best choice at pairs scoring, but there are better players than me who will take a different view.  It might be a different matter at teams scoring.


Helvic is certainly fairly intuitive as well as effective.  This is the system I play with most partners.


However, I like Halmic with its dedicated sequence for the 4-3-3-3 hands, and I like SWINE with its more constructive use of 2♥ and 2♠.


Allerton and Jagger too works for some of the best players around - it must be good enough for me.