M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

 Responder root page

Bidding

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Extensions to Lebensohl


Basic Lebensohl will help to solve your bidding difficulties in many competitive auctions.

However there are a few little extras which will help in specific situations.


Spare sequences


These extras are made possible because there are a number of sequences which have not yet been discussed.


The usual way of using most of these sequences is to define your holding in the opponents’ suit more closely - in particular whether or not you hold a stop in that suit.


Bidding to 3NT


The easiest case to analyse is that in which the artificial bid of 2NT creates an alternative route to 3NT.


The sequences in question are of the following types:-


1NT, (2x), 3NT, and

1NT, (2x), 2NT, (-), 3♣, (-), 3NT.


The intuitive agreement is that the direct route will promise a stop in the opponents’ suit and the route via 2NT will deny a stop.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 9 6

T 8 5

A J 2

K Q 7 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♥.

You have a balanced hand worth a game bid but you do not have a heart stop nor do you hold four cards in the other major.

Bid 2NT.  Partner will bid 3♣ and you will rebid 3NT showing precisely such a hand.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 9 6

K Q 7 4

A J 2

T 8 5

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♥.

You have a balanced hand worth a game bid with an excellent heart stop.

Bid 3NT.


Many partnerships reverse the meanings of the two routes.  There is little, if anything, to choose between the two approaches.  I shall use the interpretation given above throughout this site.


In search of a 4-4 major suit fit


A similar distinction can be made when you choose to bid three of the opponents’ suit to promise four cards in the other major.


This time the sequences in question are of the following types:-


1NT, (2♥), 3♥, and

1NT, (2♥), 2NT, (-), 3♣, (-), 3♥.


To be consistent with the interpretation above, the first of these forces will show a game-going hand, four cards in the other major, and a heart stop;

the second sequence also forces to game with four cards in the other major, but this time the heart stop is denied.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 9 6

T 8 5

A J 7 2

Q 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♥.

Bid 2NT.

Partner will bid 3♣ after which you will bid 3♥ showing precisely this holding.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 9 6

A J 7 2

T 8 5

Q 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♥.

Game-going values, four spades, and a good heart stop.

Bid 3♥.


Bidding a new suit


When you wish to introduce your own suit it is important to distinguish between those sequences which leave you with only two routes to the three-level and those which make a third route available.


Three routes


Frequently there will be three routes available to show your suit at or below the three-level.

This will be the case when your suit is higher-ranking than the overcall.

e.g.

1NT, (2♥), 2♠

1NT, (2♥), 3♠

1NT, (2♥), 2NT, (-), 3♣, (-), 3♠


The direct bid at the three-level is still played as game-forcing, but as the weak hand can now be shown by a bid at the two-level this frees the route via 2NT available to show a hand with invitational values.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K Q 9 2

7 4

K J 5

8 6 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♥.

Bid 3♠, natural and game-forcing.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K 9 7 6 2

7 4

J T 5

8 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♥.

Bid 2♠, weak and competitive.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A K J 7 6 2

7 4

Q 7 5

8 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♥.

Bid 2NT, and follow partner’s conversion to 3♣ with 3♠ showing precisely such a hand.

♠

♥

♦

♣

7 4

A K Q 9 2

K J 5

8 6 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♠.

This hand is game-going with a good five-card heart suit.

Bid 3♥, natural and game-forcing.

♠

♥

♦

♣

7 4

A K 9 7 6 2

J T 5

8 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♠.

You will wish to compete, but no more.

Bid 2NT.

When partner bids 3♣, as instructed, you will bid 3♥ to show just such a hand.

♠

♥

♦

♣

7 4

A K J 7 6 2

Q 7 5

8 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♠.

Well - weak or game-going?

Personally, in the absence of further bidding machinery, I bid 4♥, but there will be times when I will wish I hadn’t.

Post intermediate and above

Opener’s first bid

Opener’s rebid

This page last revised 15th Apr 2020


Two routes


There will be only two routes available when your suit is lower-ranking than the intervention.  This will always be the case when the intervention is in spades, and could also be the case when you hold a minor and the intervention is in a red suit.


The two routes are a direct bid of your suit at the three-level, and a roundabout route via 2NT.

As indicated in ‘Basic Lebensohl’ the direct route is universally played as game-forcing, and the route via 2NT as merely competitive.


But it leaves you with something of a gap when holding invitational values.


I offer something of a solution to this problem below (see double), but sometimes you will just be on a guess.


How good a stop?


In discussing ‘bidding to 3NT’ and ‘searching for a 4-4 major suit fit’ above I have suggested methods which are selected according to the stop held in the opponents suit, but I have carefully avoided (so far) defining what I mean by a stop in this context.


The problem is that most writings on the matter do not throw any more light on the matter, and, furthermore, expert practice in this matter is far from uniform.

I strongly recommend that you come to some sort of agreement on this matter.


You might wish to show a certain stop such as A or KQ.  It would also be reasonable to count Kx or QJx as genuine stops when sitting behind the overcall, in the reasonable hope that overcaller holds either the A or the K of his suit;

you might wish to show a partial stop such as Qx or Jxx;

you might wish to show a ‘better than a stop’ such as AQ;

and you might also wish to show that you hold nothing by way of a stop in the suit.


For most club players you will have to choose whether or not you hold a sufficient stop and then bid accordingly as above.

Clearly such judgement will not lead to the best contract on each and every occasion.


It seems to me that if you wish to refine your bidding in this area then a further route is required.

I include a possibility below under ‘double’.


Meanwhile you will have to use one of the routes above to show a certain stop, the other to show no stop, and fall back on judgement and guesswork on in-between holdings.


Double


Various possibilities for the double were discussed under ‘non-Lebensohl methods’.


I shall assume here that your choice was ‘double shows values’ possibly modified with ‘double is Stayman’ over a 2♣ overcall.


Double ‘shows values’


The double ‘showing values’ will typically typically have a minimum agreed strength such as nine points.

With less than game-going values it should also be suitable for take-out.

Holding this minimum strength or better with no more than two cards in the opponents’ suit and at least three cards in each of the other suits, and with no better bid available, you will usually make such a double.


If you happen to hold the hand suitable for a penalty double then pass and hope that partner is able to make a reopening double which you will pass again.


Note that, whatever minimum strength you agree for such a double, there will still be room for judgement and interpretation of the context.


To explain this point I shall merely state the two extreme cases:-


you might hold the bare minimum for a take-out double of an overcall of 2♣ holding 4-4-4-1 shape when not vulnerable.  You are all but certain to locate an eight-card fit at the two-level;

by way of contrast a vulnerable double of 2♠ on 4-4-3-2 shape risks playing at the three-level on a 4-3 fit and a combined twenty one points.  Even if partner passes it for penalties you are less than totally confident that you have sufficient defence against a long suit.  Considerably greater caution will be the order of the day.

♠

♥

♦

♣

J 7 4

A K 7 2

Q 8 7 5

8 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♣.

Ten points, and the right shape for a take-out double at a low level.

Double.

♠

♥

♦

♣

7 4

A K 7 2

Q 8 7 5

8 6 4

Partner opened 1NT and RHO overcalled 2♠.

Nine points and 4-4-3-2 shape.

Double would not be wrong, subject to the partnership agreement, but with minimum values think twice before committing the partnership to the three-level.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 7

A 7 2

K 8 7 5

K Q 6 4

Partner opens 1NT and RHO overcalls 2♠.

Fourteen points in a balanced hand, and not four cards in the other major.

Double first, then rebid 3NT to show just such a holding with a partial stop in the opponents’ suit.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 7

A K 8 2

8 7 5

A 7 6 4

Partner opens 1NT and RHO overcalls 2♠.

Thirteen points, four cards in the other major, and a partial stop in the opponents’ suit.

Double first, then rebid 3♠ to show precisely this holding.

♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 7

A K 8 7 2

8 7 5

Q 6 4

A good five-card heart suit and invitational values.

Double first.

If partner responds in a minor rebid 3♥ to show precisely this holding.

If partner responds 3♥ you will still be on a guess, but no worse off than when you started.


The Lebensohl approach as expounded above is excellent and will place you up there with the majority of tournament players as far as your methods are concerned.


Alternatively rehash (and improve) the standard methodology above to get Allerton and Jagger.


There is, though, a certain logic to extending your methods even further by adopting Rubinsohl (or transfer Lebensohl).


Double is Stayman


Whatever agreements you come to in general there is much to be said for playing different methods when the opponents make a natural overcall of 2♣.

There is absolutely no reason why the ‘double is Stayman’ agreement discussed earlier should not be combined with the Lebensohl methods espoused on this page.  If you make this choice you will probably agree to use the same method when your opponents make any artificial 2♣ overcall which does not promise both majors.


Stronger holdings


With better than minimum values you will be considering a further bid, and this is where I attempt to address the problems outlined above.


Following your initial double:-


a rebid of 3NT suggests 13 points, no four-card major, and a partial stop in the opponents’ suit;

a rebid of the opponents’ suit in the three-route suggests 13 points, four cards in a major, and a partial stop in the opponents’ suit;

a rebid in a new suit in the ‘two route’ scenario outlined above suggests a five-card suit and invitational values.

Context  -  Partner opened 1NT - RHO made a natural suit overcall.