M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

 Responder root page

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

Negative free bid


The negative free bid was much loved by early theorists both within the Acol system and also in most of the rest of the bridge world.


It derives from a time when the opponents’ overcall was more likely than not to promise full opening values, and so the likelihood of a substantial contract your way was greatly diminished.

Furthermore, you no longer had to bid just to keep the auction alive - partner would have a further opportunity.

It therefore seemed to make sense to use the bid to tell partner about a safe escape - typically a six-card suit with a poor fit for partner.


Times have changed.

The opponents’ overcall is now far more likely to be made on a hand of less than opening strength, perhaps merely to suggest a lead in defence or even with the quite ungentlemanly aim of disturbing your constructive bidding and laying the groundwork for a possible high-level sacrifice.

Furthermore, overcaller’s partner is more than ever likely to go shooting off into the stratosphere with no more to his hand than a few cards in partner’s suit.  It can be very difficult for you or your partner to reenter the auction in such circumstances if you have done no more than pass initially.


To counter such methods it seems to me that you must retain a variety of constructive options for when the contract belongs to you.


By far the simplest constructive move on a non-fit hand is a simple forcing change of suit, just as in the uncontested auction.


The negative free bid comes in two versions.


In the first it makes no promise of any kind regarding the values held - it is in essence a weak take-out to be left alone at all costs.


In the second version it promises the normal minimum values associated with the bid (e.g. ‘Rule of fourteen’ or something similar for the bid of a new suit at the two-level) but no more than that.


In either case, with a game-going hand you will have to force in some other way.


The usual option will be to extend the remit of the double, but alternative methods might be based around a jump in the new suit or a bid in the opponents’ suit.


None of these variations come with my seal of approval - the strong bids mentioned above all have better uses.



Strongly recommended is the modern day standard of ‘natural and forcing’.


This is the one you will find in all of my analyses of specific sequences.

Opener’s rebid

Not recommended

Opener’s first bid

Context  -  Acol bidding - Responder’s first bid - partner opened one major - opponents overcalled in a suit - no support - new suit.

This page last revised 12th May 2020