M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

 Responder root page

Home

Conventions

Hands

Theory

The opponents made a two-suited overcall


This time we have opened the bidding and one of our opponents has overcalled with a two-suited bid.


This is a specialist situation and needs a specialist solution - or at least it needs specific partnership agreement.

If you come across these bids before you have come to a partnership agreement on the matter then you can do no better than fall back on a number of


generic agreements


Note that these first methods are not my recommendation in this very special case.


Double  is for take-out (frequently this will suggest just the one remaining suit);

2NT     when partner opens a major shows a good raise to three or more;

3NT      natural and to play;

a lowest level bid in a new suit is natural and forcing;

a bid in a suit implied by your opponents is an all-purpose force, but specifically searches for a no trump stop;

raises of partner’s suit show length, but not strength.

Beginner and above

Intermediate and above


Note that the support meaning of 2NT has been lost in this allocation.  It will be replaced shortly.


Double

shows values:-


that is - a hand of 10+ points lacking primary support for partner and without a long strong suit of its own.

It does not promise a crippling holding in either or both of the opponents’ suits, nor does it say anything about the holding in the artificial suit bid by your opponents.

Although this bid will only rarely be passed for penalties in the first instance, subsequent doubles by either member of the partnership will show a holding in the opponents’ suit and will be intended as penalty doubles.

Note that, in the absence of a further bid from your opponents, the only pass available to opener is a penalty pass - in all other respects the bid is forcing.

Furthermore, if advancer makes only a minimum response, then the auction remains forcing for one round. With this agreement, opener can pass on his rebid knowing that the auction will not die.


This leaves us with cue-bids in the opponents’ implied suit(s) and bids in suits which have neither been bid naturally nor implied.

Your methods will depend, at least to an extent, on the nature of the overcall.


Opponents have specified just one suit


Your opponents’ methods go against my instincts.  I prefer to tell partner precisely which two suits I hold as quickly as possible. However, you will come across these bids, usually when facing a major suit opening.


Cue-bid in the opponents’ implied suit


It is standard practice to use the cue-bid of the opponents’ implied suit to show a good raise of partner’s suit - that is four-card support and at least invitational values.


Direct raises of partner’s suit

are competitive, and not as strong as a limit raise.  Typically a lowest-level bid at the three-level would suggest a sound four-card raise to the two-level.


Bid in a new suit


There are two suits which have neither been bid naturally nor implied.  One of these will be overcaller’s second suit, but the chances are that if you have length in one of these two suits then overcaller’s suit is the other one.


With this thought in mind the simplest method, and perfectly effective, is to play that a bid in either of these two suits is natural and forcing for one round.


Opponents have specified two suits


Typical of such bids is the immediate cue-bid in a minor suit by those playing Michael’s, or some variation on Ghestem.  All of my recommended systems such as SpoDo incorporate three bids of this variety.


Direct raise of partner’s suit


As above, a direct raise will suggest at least four-card support with less than invitational values.


And what about jump responses?


Such bids are hardly mentioned in most writings on the subject.

Simply because of the level of bidding they will be rare beasts, but here is a fairly obvious suggestion:-


a jump bid in an opponent’s implied suit is a splinter, agreeing partner’s suit and promising void or singleton in the bid suit;

a jumps in the fourth suit is a fit-jump - after all, advancer already knows whether or not there is a double-fit - this is your opportunity to put partner in the same happy position.

Which cue-bid?


I mentioned above that there is an ambiguity in the concept of ‘the lower cue-bid’.


This definition works well whenever your opponents have promised two adjacent suits, as is the case with a Michael’s cue-bid over a minor suit opening or an unusual 2NT over a major suit opening, but when the two suits promised are not adjacent then it can lead to just a little confusion.


Let me look at just one possibility:-


that is when partner’s opening 1♠ is overcalled with 2NT promising clubs and hearts (not common, but perfectly possible) -

partner’s suit is spades and the fourth suit is diamonds.


With the definition above, 3♣ will promise good support and will be forcing to 3♠, and 3♥ will promise a good holding in diamonds and will be forcing to 4♦.


The alternative allocation would be that 3♣ promises a good holding in diamonds and is forcing to 3♦, and that 3♥ promises good support for spades and forces to 3♠.


It is clear to me that the second of these allocations is the more efficient.


I will therefore modify the guidance given above and suggest that, in respect of partner’s suit and the fourth suit, the cheaper cue-bid should show a good holding in the cheaper of the two suits and the more expensive cue-bid should promise a good holding in the other suit.


No anchor suit!


Unlikely, but not quite impossible - at one time an overcall of 1NT was used in this way.  This may be the only place in which you find the possibility discussed - however briefly.

The opponents have promised two suits other than that bid by partner, but with no indication which two.


The absence of a cue-bid presents a difficulty, but it is easily overcome.


A simple solution is that any immediate raise should be constructive - that is - a good raise.  (It is tempting to play it as weak and preemptive, passing initially with a stronger hand, but your opponents could then play a trick on you with a quick pass on your left depriving both you and your partner of a further bid.)  2NT, if available, can also be used to show a good raise;

any lowest-level bid in a new suit is natural and forcing;

a jump in a new suit is a fit-jump.


With other hand-types you will pass first - a pass from LHO is all but impossible, after which you can either make a weak preemptive raise in partner’s suit, or a weak competitive bid in the fourth suit.


Simple - but it should be sufficient.

Post intermediate and above

You will realize quite rapidly that such a system is less than ideal.

With only one suit remaining the double is certainly not being used to its full potential;

the bidding will frequently already be at the level of 2NT or higher, depriving you of any support bid for partner;

even at a lower level of bidding there will usually not be the bidding space available to reach a natural contract of 2NT via an initial double, and so this destination is lost;

there will frequently be two cue-bids available thus opening the way to greater definition in your methods;

your opponents already know whether or not there is a double fit, but you have no means to determine whether or not this is the case - they have the initiative.


With these thoughts in mind we have a starting point for locating a more precise defence to such bids.


A search of various likely sources will reveal a variety of methods.  They have much in common with each other, but the strengths associated with each of the various bids can vary tremendously.  The suggestions which follow draw heavily on an article by David Bakhshi in the December 2010 edition of ‘English Bridge’, together with some thoughts from Ron Klinger’s ‘Bridge conventions, defences and countermeasures’.


Classifying the bid


As we have seen, there are many possible systems of two-suited overcalls.  It would be foolhardy to attempt to create and learn a separate method against each possible variation, and if you were to try such an approach you would be completely lost when encountering an unknown one.

Instead it is vital that you can categorise your opponents’ bid and then invoke the method which you have agreed for dealing with bids in that category.


There are three aspects to placing the bid in a category.


The first of these is strength.


Only very occasionally will your opponents’ bid promise a strong hand.

Some variations will promise a weak hand.

Most variations will be either ‘wide-ranging’ or ‘weak or strong’.

As in all competitive bidding situations, you will tend to compete vigorously against strong hands on a weak holding, provided that you have some sort of fit with partner.

You will bid as constructively as possible against intervention which is known to be weak with some expectation that the hand might belong to your side.

If your opponents’ bid covers both weak and strong possibilities then, in the absence of any other clues, you will tend to place it at the more common weaker end of the possible spectrum and then bid constructively in the first place, as indicated above.


The second is ‘specific or ambiguous?’


Some of these overcalls will promise two specific suits.  Some will promise either any two suits, or one specified suit together with a second undefined one.

These situations will be treated differently in the suggestions which follow.


The third is ‘What length is promised?’


Most frequently these bids will promise 5-5 shape in the two suits, but it will not be uncommon for this requirement to be extended to 5-4 or even 4-4 shape, at least in some specific sequences.

This knowledge will not change your counter-methods, but it may well affect your judgement in the subsequent auction.


Methods common to all categories


Bids in no trumps

are natural and non-forcing.  Ten to twelve points with stoppers in the opponents’ known suit(s).


We are left with a bid in the fourth suit and a cue-bid in the higher of the opponents’ suits (but see below).


One of these will be used to show a competitive offering in the fourth suit, and the other will be used to show a holding in the fourth suit with at least invitational values.

They can be be allocated either way round - both allocations will be encountered.

I have a slight preference that both cue-bids should show values, and so the direct bid in the fourth suit becomes the natural competitive and limited offering.

Opener’s first bid


As two suits have been specified you now have two cue-bids available in your opponents’ suits along with one further bid in a genuinely new suit.


Good raise


It is standard to use one of the cue-bids to show a good raise of partner’s suit.

For the moment I shall go along with the usual guidance that the good raise should be shown by a cue-bid in the lower of the opponents’ suits (but note that there can be some ambiguity which I shall consider in the ‘post-intermediate’ section below).

Context  -  Acol bidding - Responder’s first bid - partner opened one major - opponents intervened.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A 9 5 2

8 6

Q 9 4

K Q 6 3

2♥ shows the black suits.

Bid 2NT - natural and invitational -

unless you prefer to double as defined below.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

T 8 6

8 6

K Q 9 4

K Q 6 3

2♥ shows the black suits.

Double.

You will be happy to punish an escape into a minor, and partner might be able to punish an escape into spades.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 9 7 4

A K T 7 5

A J

8 2

Pass.

If RHO had bid spades you would have doubled for penalties.

As it is you can pass the buck back to partner.

With the hand above partner will double for penalties.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

2♥

x

3♣

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A T 5 2

8 6

K Q 9

K Q 6 3

2♥ shows the black suits.

Double, showing values, in anticipation of a penalty double,

or bid 3NT to play,

depending on the vulnerability.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

Q J 7 4

K 9 5 3

T 8 6

7 2

2NT promises both minors.

Bid 3♥.

Such a direct raise is better than a pass, but that is all.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2NT

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

7 4

K J T 3

A K 8 6

9 7 2

2♥ is Michael’s, promising spades and another.

Bid 2♠.

This is a good raise to 3♥ or higher.

With this hand you will pass partner’s simple conversion to 3♥.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

7 4

K J T 3

A K 8 6

A 7 2

2♥ is Michael’s, promising spades and another.

Bid 2♠.

This is a good raise to 3♥ or higher.

With this hand you will raise partner’s rebid of 3♥ to game.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

Q 7 4

K T 3

Q 6

A K 8 6 4

2♥ is Michael’s, promising spades and another.

Bid 3♣.

This is natural and forcing.

You would like to finish in 4♥, or just possibly 3NT.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

8 7 5 3

J T 8 4

A 5 3

7 6

2♥ shows spades and clubs.

Bid 3♥.

This offers no more than competitive support for partner’s suit.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

J T 8 4

7 6

A K 3 2

K 7 3

2♠ shows hearts and clubs.

Bid 3♣.

This bid in the lower of the opponents’ suits promises four-card support, at least invitational values, and is forcing to at least 3♠.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♠

2♠

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

8 5 3

7 6

A J T 7 5 3

9 5

2♥ shows clubs and spades..

Partner’s suit is hearts - the fourth suit is diamonds.

Bid 3♦.  When the opponents have specified two suits, as here, this bid is merely competitive and not forcing.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A 7 3

7 6 4

A K T 5 3

J 4

2♥ shows clubs and spades..

Partner’s suit is hearts - the fourth suit is diamonds.

Bid 2♠.  This bid in the higher of the opponents’ suits shows a good holding in the fourth suit (but see below).

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2♥

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A K T 5

K 8 7 4

7

J T 6 3

2NT is ‘unusual’ promising both minors.

Bid 4♦ promising four-card heart support with at most one diamond.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♥

2NT

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

K T 8 5

A K 7 6 4

7 3

J T

2NT is ‘unusual’ promising both minors.

Bid 4♥ promising four-card spade support together with a good heart suit..

You

LHO

Pard

RHO



1♠

2NT

?