M J Bridge
♦
♠
♥
♣
Bidding
RHO changed suit
LHO has opened, partner has passed, and RHO has made an unlimited response -
At the beginner stage there is no great need even to recognize this as anything of a special case. Just treat it as a normal overcall situation and bid, double, or pass as you would in the immediate overcall seat.
Beginner and above
♠
♥
♦
♣
A J T 7 6
8 6
A K 8 6
5 3
I would usually make an immediate overcall of 1♠ on this hand when RHO opens 1♣ or 1♥.
It certainly indicates an excellent defensive lead.
However, in the sandwich seat with just a somewhat broken five-
|
You |
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
|
|
1♣ |
- |
1♥ |
|
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Note that double might be defined with greater precision as part of your system of two-
1NT
The following assumes that yours is not a passed hand. That is a special case and is treated briefly on its own page.
Robert Todd and his team on Advinbridge.com suggest natural and strong with stops in both suits on a range of about 15 to 18.
Karen Walker on kwbridge.com also suggests strong and natural with stops, but on a range of 16 to 18.
Bridgebum.com on the other hand makes no mention of anything other than the ‘Sandwich no trump’ convention.
All the above are American sites, but I don’t think that affects the decision in any way in this particular context.
Remember, even with eighteen or nineteen points it is still possible that your opponents hold the balance, and LHO knows exactly where to start his defence.
As indicated above, if you do hold the strong balanced hand there is much to be said for ‘lyin’ low and sayin’ nuffin’.
So I have a slight preference for playing a two-
Bidding one of the opponents’ suits
These bids will usually be used alongside double and 1NT to show various two-
Two-
Such a method is likely to feature any or all of 1NT, 2♣, 2♦, 2NT, double, and any available cue-
This will almost certainly include the ‘sandwich no trump’ referred to above.
Such methods are discussed on the page two-
Intermediate and above
RHO’s response is unlimited;
LHO might yet hold undisclosed additional strength;
you are in the sandwich seat;
and you are the meat in the sandwich -
The opponents will usually hold at least eighteen points between them. There is every possibility that partner will hold next to nothing, and if opener is equipped with a penalty double or some equivalent device (such as a forcing pass), as he may well be, then life could get very nasty very quickly.
It is up to you to decide just how scared of the possible calamities you wish to be.
Expert writings on this topic are strangely varied.
As examples:-
Terence Quested at the Pattaya bridge club emphasises the dangers and advocates extreme caution;
Barbara Seagram and Marc Smith in ‘25 ways to compete in the bidding’ (which you can see online) state ‘we cannot overemphasize the dangers of bidding in the sandwich seat’;
Eric Crowhurst suggests some caution linked to the idea that there is little point in making a ‘constructive’ overcall;
and Barry Rigal makes no mention of the dangers but concentrates on the constructive use of the available bids.
Eric Crowhurst links his advice with the excellent observation that if the opponents subsequently turn out to have limited holdings and the auction appears likely to peter out at a low level you may well get a subsequent opportunity to enter the fray.
And various discussion forums on the net tend to concentrate on the use of one particular bid -
The dangers associated with bidding in this seat are certainly a relevant consideration, but on the other hand they should not frighten you into eternal silence. The main thing is to retain something of a safety net just in case partner has absolutely nothing and the opposition have thoughts of a penalty double (which is quite probable).
This safety net will usually manifest itself either either in the form of a long quality suit, or as a two-
So let us start with the non-
Bid in a new suit
Bids in a new suit will be natural.
In general they will be made on a robust six-
Take-
The principle to bear in mind is that partner might have to play at the one-
♠
♥
♦
♣
A K J 7 6 4
8
A K 8 6
5 3
Every hope of making seven tricks.
Bid 2♠, or even 3♠ when not vulnerable.
|
You |
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
|
|
1♥ |
- |
2♣ |
|
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
♠
♥
♦
♣
J T 7 6 5 3 2
8
K J T
5 3
You might have considered an immediate overcall of 3♠ at favourable vulnerability, but with every likelihood of making just four or five tricks this would be a seriously unwise choice in the sandwich seat.
Pass.
|
You |
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
|
|
1♥ |
- |
2♣ |
|
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
♠
♥
♦
♣
A 7 6
6
K 8 6
K Q J 7 5 3
1♣ was announced as ‘could be two’, and 1♦ was alerted as a relay.
Bid 2♣ -
|
You |
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
|
|
1♣ |
- |
1♦ |
|
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
♠
♥
♦
♣
9 8
K 3
A Q J 8 7 4
A T 5
1♦ could be three-
Fourteen points, a reasonably robust suit, and a potentially well-
Bid 2♦ (provided that you play it as natural).
|
You |
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
|
|
1♦ |
- |
1♥ |
|
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
♠
♥
♦
♣
A K 6 4
J 9 8
A K 8 6
5 3
Double if not vulnerable.
Partner can choose to play in either diamonds or spades at the two-
|
You |
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
|
|
1♥ |
- |
2♣ |
|
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
♠
♥
♦
♣
5 3
J 9 8
A K 8 6
A K 6 4
Pass.
Partner will have to choose at the three-
|
You |
LHO |
Pard |
RHO |
|
|
1♠ |
- |
2♥ |
|
? |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Post-
At an improver stage there is still no need to take any clever methods on board.
But for reasons which are considered below you should make your overcalls that little bit sounder:-
suit overcalls should be on suits of genuine good quality and usually near opening values;
doubles should be based on sound values and should be genuinely shape-
the 1NT overcall will be played on a range of at least fifteen to eighteen with stops in both of the opponents’ suits;
and don’t overcall a natural 2NT (either bid 1NT, or sit back and enjoy the defence -
This page last revised 4th Jul 2020
Context -
| Opener |
| Overcaller |
| Responder |
| Advancer |
| Opener's rebid |
| Overcaller's rebid and beyond |
| Responder's rebid and beyond |
| The continuing auction |