Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Theory

Beginner and above

Advancer’s next bid

RHO passed


Note that I do not refer to this as ‘the protective seat’ in the present context.


‘Protective’ refers to the fact that one of the things which you are protecting is the possibility that partner might have a significant holding in the opponents’ suit with no bid available - only on this occasion the opponents don’t have a suit - at least not one that you know about.


When LHO opens one of a suit and RHO passes he is known to be extremely limited.  The odds are strongly in favour of partner holding at least a modicum of values.


Now that LHO has started with a limited opening bid RHO might hold as many as ten points for his pass (facing a weak no trump) - you can no longer be certain that partner must hold hidden values.  Accordingly you enter the fray with a degree of risk attached.

Against this, RHO might equally hold zero points with no suitable escape.  In some circumstances there might even be a game contract your way.


If you are looking for some ideas on what you should do you will find these lower down the page, but first


Some Maths (or arithmetic or probability - call it what you will)


You know a lot about opener’s hand - you know very little about partner’s hand other than he does not hold a hand suitable for some kind of overcall or double - you know very little about RHO’s hand apart from an upper limit - and you know everything about your own hand.


So let’s concentrate initially on the two hands which you know a lot about.


Place opener’s points in the middle of his range and add on the known points in your own hand.  Whatever’s left out of 40 will be within a point of partner’s and RHO’s combined holding, and on average it will be split more or less equally between them.


This is how the sums work out:-

Context - Acol bidding - overcaller - opponents opened 1NT - partner passed - overcalling in fourth seat.

This page last revised 24th Oct 2020

Opponents opened a strong no trump




Assume LHO points

Your points

Remaining

Partner's average

Av combined holding

16

8

16

8

16

16

9

15

7

16

16

10

14

7

17

16

11

13

6

17

16

12

12

6

18

16

13

11

5

18

16

14

10

5

19

16

15

9

4

19

16

16

8

4

20

Opponents opened a weak no trump




13

8

19

9

17

13

9

18

9

18

13

10

17

8

18

13

11

16

8

19

13

12

15

7

19

13

13

14

7

20

13

14

13

6

20

13

15

12

6

21

13

16

11

5

21


Note


1. The above assumes ranges of 12 to 14 and 15 to 17 respectively for weak and strong no trumps.  The calculations are easily modified for alternative ranges.


2. You will have noticed that I have taken the pessimistic view of partner’s holding when there an odd number of points outstanding.


3. An alternative calculation based on the assumption that responder holds points at the mid-point of his possible range is to be found on the net.  This leads to a slightly rosier view of your combined holding, particularly when facing a strong no trump.

I believe the basis of my calculation to be more statistically correct.  However, the conclusions do not differ drastically and the recommended actions will vary only marginally.

So, what should you do?


First of all, don’t be overawed by the opponents’ opening bid, the vulnerability, or your own limited points holding - this is not the time to remain politely and cringingly silent.


That 1NT will all too often struggle home on a minimum combined holding and tends to score well.

Even if you and your partner hold no more than a combined 16 points you will frequently have a better-scoring contract available at the two-level if either you hold length or you can locate a fit.


If you have anything resembling a decent six-card suit it will almost always be correct to introduce this.


If you can locate a fit with anything approaching a bit of shape in your hand then a two-level contract will usually be a good option.


And what do I mean by ‘a bit of shape’.


In the context of the American game and the strong no trump Mel Colchamiro suggests the ‘balancing rule of 2’.

By this he means that you should find a bid whenever you have at least two shortness points, which he define as either a void, a singleton or two doubletons—no matter what your high card point strength is.

That pretty much boils down to any hand which is not 4-3-3-3 or 4-4-3-2.


The science behind this ‘rule’ is a little hazy, but without doubt it is good guideline provided that your partner is on the same wavelength.


Be a little bit careful if your hand is particularly flat, or if you are vulnerable or your point-count is low against a strong no trump, but in general - and particularly at pairs scoring - it will pay to produce some kind of offering at this point.


Methods


Bidding your long suit naturally is clearly straightforward, but this will leave you without any means of searching for a fit with, say, 5-4 shape.


Some kind of simple agreement is recommended.


Opponents opened a strong no trump


Elsewhere I have presented my working categorisation of a strong no trump as one which guarantees at least fifteen points.


Easiest, and probably best, is just to more or less ignore the possibility of a game your way.


The standard method against a strong no trump is D.O.N.T..  It is simple and effective.

If you happen to have an excessively long suit, with or without game aspirations, you will just have to jump in the suit, or double first and then jump in the suit (probably the stronger route).


Alternatively you may agree to use whichever method you use in the immediate overcall position or against a weak no trump.


Opponents opened a weak no trump


This time the best method is far from obvious.


Game your way has become a realistic possibility but but the odds are still against it.


You could do far worse, particularly at pairs, than to sacrifice the possibility of a game contract and to play D.O.N.T. as against a strong no trump.


Alternatively, if you choose to retain the strong double there is a lot to be said for playing the same system as in the immediate overcall position, be it Landy, Asptro, or whatever (you may agree to drop the requirement for a double by a point or two).


I rather like the idea of combining the strong double (possibly suitably adjusted) with the D.O.N.T principle of showing two-suited holdings at the two-level - this will allow you to compete with 4-4 shape - but I must admit that I have not road-tested this one at a serious level.


Take your choice - any one of the above will be better than no agreement at all.