M J Bridge
♦
♠
♥
♣
Bidding
Strong over weak
This maxim usually comes as part of a pair, the other being ‘weak over strong’.
Bid strong hands over weak openings.
Opponents opened with a weak bid
This is not followed quite as widely as ‘weak over strong’, but it is still recommended.
The opponents’ bid is in effect an advance sacrifice.
One school of thought is to ‘preempt over a preempt’.
It is certainly true that you will not infrequently be able to make a part-
Against this, there is little point in going down in a contract when you were already scoring a positive if the opponents’ contract failed.
More importantly, the opponents have already deprived you of bidding space on a deal which may well be rightfully yours. You need to retain as many constructive options as possible as you search for the best contract.
And most importantly, it is not uncommon for these auctions to spiral rapidly to a high level -
If your overcall might lie anywhere from ‘preemptive’ to ‘strong hand’ then partner will be at a complete loss regarding his next action.
My guideline is that your immediate overcall should be at least a sound opener.
Ideally it will contain some defensive potential -
And if you do happen to hold the weaker hand worth a making part-
Question
My guideline
How strong should I be to overcall a weak opening bid?
At least a good opener.
Sometimes it is not obvious if an opponent’s opening bid should be classified as weak, standard, or strong.
I will propose the following ‘working rule’:-
treat the bid as weak if it guarantees a maximum of ten HCP.
In the case of an opening bid which may be weak or strong, such as the multi two diamonds, start by assuming that it is weak and bid accordingly, unless you have specifically made some other agreement.
An instructive deal
The following deal comes from a recent match in the county league, in which I was playing with an excellent but occasional partner.
It proves nothing in itself, but it certainly demonstrates some of the concepts considered above.
Beginner and above
This page last revised 27th Nov 2019
Context -
♠
♥
♦
♣
K 7 5 4
K J T 9 6 3
K T 3
♠
♥
♦
♣
J 6 3 2
Q 8 7 4 2
9 6
9 3
♠
♥
♦
♣
9 8
A 5
7 2
A Q 8 7 6 5 4
♠
♥
♦
♣
A Q T
A Q J 8 5 4
K J T 2
I was sitting North as dealer with NS vulnerable.
My initial pass is routine as is a weak 3♣ from East.
South, who could see the offensive potential of his hand doubled. What follows would have been little different had he chosen to bid 3♥.
West raised rather feebly to 4♣, I offered 4♥, and East bid 5♣.
I then chose, perhaps unwisely at the prevailing vulnerability, to bid 5♥ confident that we had a big fit, and also that partner had sufficient defence should the opponents try for a slam.
How wrong could I be.
With the favourable lie of the spade and diamond honours EW make thirteen tricks in clubs or no trumps, or twelve in diamonds. Meanwhile NS can make seven tricks in hearts.
This means that 3♥x is an excellent sacrifice against the opponents’ game, but a sacrifice against the slam will not pay.
Swap the ♥A and one of the other aces between the EW hands, and clubs will still make twelve tricks whereas NS can now make eight tricks in hearts.
On such a layout 4♥x becomes a good sacrifice compared with the club game, but 5♥ will still be a bid too far.
On this analysis my bid of 5♥ was clearly misjudged, but bear in mind that I had expected to find at least one more trick in partner’s hand.
The outcome was that EW got pushed in to 6♣ (which I was happy about at the time) and proceeded to make thirteen tricks (which I was less happy about) for a score of 940.
This was less of a disaster than I had anticipated, as 6♣ was also the contract at the other table for a flat board. I don’t know what route they followed to get there.
But, if I had left 4♥ there is little doubt that our opponents would have stopped in 5♣ for a score of 440 and 11 imps to our team.
Moral -
| Opener |
| Overcaller |
| Responder |
| Advancer |
| Opener's rebid |
| Overcaller's rebid and beyond |
| Responder's rebid and beyond |
| The continuing auction |