Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Theory

Artificial or Natural


A second important principle relates to whether your opponents’ bid is natural or artificial.


If their bid is artificial and strong (as in the Precision club) then you should adopt some specific defence.


If the bid does not promise additional strength then you must agree on your method.

Simplest is to treat the bid as natural (double for take-out and a bid in the opponents’ suit as artificial and forcing) in all situations, but more common, and in my opinion superior, is to vary your methods according to whether or not the bid is natural.


If an opponent’s bid is natural then a double will be for take-out;

if their bid is artificial then a bid of their suit will be natural,

and a double will show length and strength in that suit or will have a specific conventional meaning.


As with the previous principle, these are default assumptions which can be overridden by agreement in specific situations.


It is not always quite clear as to what constitutes ‘natural’ and ‘artificial’ in the above.

This applies particularly to opening bids of 1♣ (and sometimes 1♦ as in Precision).

Such opening bids should be announced as, for example, ‘could be two’.  If they are not announced then the bid should guarantee at least three cards in the bid suit.

However, it is not uncommon for such bids to be alerted, or announced as (say) ‘phoney’, ‘nebulous’, ‘fishing’, ‘prepared’, or some such description.


In all such cases you should ask what is the minimum possible holding in the suit, and if that number is less than three then you should treat the bid as artificial.


If at least a three-card holding is promised then simplest is to treat it as natural.


Note that there are partnerships out there (but not at a particularly high level) who have never actually agreed exactly what such a bid promises.  Such partnerships tend to hold at least three cards in the suit, and the bid is most easily treated as natural.

Beginner and above

This page last revised 4th Mar 2019

Question

My guideline

When is a loosely defined one-level bid treated as artificial?

When it does not promise at least three cards in the suit.

Question

My guideline

What happens if they cannot define their bid clearly?

Treat it as natural.


Once you are happy with the aims and principles you should return to the page ‘overcalling’ and follow the links from there for the considerations relating to the opponents’ specific opening bid.

Context - overcaller - considerations and principles.