Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Openers rebid

root page

Theory

Your hand is balanced


This page assumes that partner holds from six (possibly five) to nine points with no natural change of suit available to him.

Five point hands are likely to tend towards ‘good’ (!) or a poor fit for your first suit. and nine point hands are likely to be of the ‘poor’ variety.

For a fuller discussion see responder’s first bid.


As your hand is balanced you should hold from fifteen to nineteen points, possibly after a little minor revaluation.


Let’s start with the easy ones.


Fifteen points


Many beginners are tempted to rebid 2NT on fifteen or sixteen points in this situation, just as they intended to do over a two-level response in a new suit, but the situation is quite different.  Now that partner has limited his hand to a maximum of nine points you will not have enough for 3NT, so don’t do it.  If you have a balanced-fifteen point hand just pass.

Intermediate and above

Seventeen or eighteen variations


(As above, this may include an excellent sixteen suitably revalued.)


I have heard top class players argue passionately that with eighteen points you should jump directly to 3NT.  The raise to 2NT will therefore show precisely seventeen points.  Their argument is that with eighteen points opposite six to nine you will reach the magic total of twenty five points three times out of four - so go for it.


They are neither right nor wrong - the method which they recommend is perfectly satisfactory but neither significantly better nor worse than the traditional approach above - and their logic and understanding of probability theory is shallow at best.


An analysis of alternative approaches


The following is based on the assumption that on two balanced hands 3NT should be bid with a combined total of twenty five points and that the bidding should stop below this level with less.  It overlooks the relevance of judgement and revaluation, but neither of these considerations detracts from the underlying argument.


There are eight possible combinations of seventeen or eighteen facing six to nine, all more or less equally probable.

Of these eight combinations five reach a total of twenty five or more, and the other three reach a total of twenty four or less.


So, I will offer you four options


Option 1.

Rebid 2NT with precisely seventeen points and rebid 3NT with eighteen or nineteen points.  Clearly partner will raise 2NT to 3NT with eight or nine.

With this combination of methods you will get all five of the stronger combinations correct and two out of three of the weaker combinations will stop in 2NT.  The only error will be on eighteen facing six, on which you will find yourself in a game contract with a combined total of twenty four points.


Option 2.

Rebid 2NT with either seventeen or eighteen points and rebid 3NT directly with nineteen (traditional Acol).

Responder always raises 2NT to 3NT with seven or more points.

With this combination of methods you will again get the five stronger holdings correct along with two of the weaker holdings.  The only difference is that this time it will be the seventeen opposite seven combination which you get wrong.


Option 3.

And if you play the rebid of 2NT to show seventeen or eighteen and agree that partner will raise this with a minimum of eight points but pass with six or seven then you will get four of the strong holdings and three of the weak holdings correct, but you will fail to find 3NT with eighteen facing seven.


So, seven correct and one wrong in each case.


Option 4.

lies midway between options two and three.  Responder will always raise with eight and has the discretion to raise with a good-looking seven.


Imps scoring (teams)


Playing teams you will discount options 3 and 4, not wishing to miss any possible game contracts.


The difference between options one and two is all but negligible.

Choose either one of them - it doesn’t much matter which but just make sure that you are both playing the same one.


Pairs scoring


Playing pairs there is nothing of any significance to choose between the four methods.

Choose whichever you like.


I may be at odds with the majority of experts here but I have a preference for option 4 - but, to be honest, you won’t come to a lot of harm if you stick with the traditional Acol guidance.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 7 6

K Q 7 6

K 8 6

Q 3

Pass.

Do not invite with 2NT on just fifteen points facing partner’s maximum of nine.

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

1NT

-

?









Nineteen points


Partner has a minimum of six points (five perhaps, but give it a go anyway).  Combined with your nineteen this gives a total of at least twenty five (twenty four on a bad day).

Bid 3NT.

♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 7 6

K Q 7 6

K Q 6

K 3

Bid 2NT, showing seventeen or eighteen points in a balanced hand.

(Do not reverse into 2♠ to show your strength - this would promise a fifth heart.

Note that partner has already denied four spades with his initial response.)

You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

1NT

-

?








♠

♥

♦

♣

A J 7 6

K Q 7 6

K Q

K Q 3

You downgraded your hand originally because of the doubleton diamond honours, but now you must act.

Bid 3NT.


You

LHO

Pard

RHO

1♥

-

1NT

-

?








Beginner and above

Responder’s first bid

Responder’s rebid

This section last revised 10th Dec 2020

Context  -  Acol bidding - opener’s rebid - you opened one of a suit in first or second seat, LHO passed, and partner responded 1NT.


And now for the ‘not quite so straightforward’ cases.


Sixteen points


Sixteen points in your hand will need nine points opposite to reach the magic total of twenty five.


At pairs scoring always pass - you might make the game about 1 in 4 times (that is 3 bad boards to every good board) and that will not pay off in anything except the occasional short term - even your invitational bid of 2NT will be one too many on occasion.


At teams scoring you will be more tempted because of the value of the game bonus.

You might choose to agree to make an invitational raise to game on such hands, but I will suggest an alternative approach and that is to push the responsibility back onto responder.


When discussing the 1NT response I went along with Chris Jagger’s suggestion that the 1NT response should indicate that responder has no interest in game facing opener’s balanced 15 or 16.

He is unlikely to hold as many as nine points, and if he does they will be of the miserable variety.


This leads to the conclusion that you should always pass with sixteen points.

The corollary will be that your invitational raise to 2NT will always promise seventeen or eighteen points (but see below), which will make responder’s next decision considerably more straightforward.


Only invite with 2NT on a sixteen point hand with a good reason e.g. - a good five-card suit and/or promising intermediates - in other words a hand which you think is really worth seventeen points in the first place.


Seventeen or eighteen points


(or an excellent sixteen, but only if revalued as above)


Traditional Acol gives a clear guideline on this matter (but see below for possible alternatives).

With seventeen or eighteen points you make an invitational raise to 2NT.