M J Bridge
♦
♠
♥
♣
Bidding
Openers rebid
root page
This page last updated 23rd Jul 2020
Context -
Intermediate and above
Partner passed
The method presented under improvers’ methods will serve you well.
On this page I do no more than discuss the alternative possibilities, and in slightly greater detail.
RHO made a suit bid
I have nothing further to add to the improvers method in this respect.
Always pass.
RHO doubled
The only reference I have found to this situation (in a somewhat limited search) was on the ‘Bridgebum’ website where it was suggested that the ‘Helvic wriggle’ could be used after both 1NT, (x),.. and 1NT, (-
Presumably the same thought could apply to any other form of wriggle -
Certainly that approach with its consistency of method will make for the easy life, but I have my doubts -
For a start partner is now known not to hold a five-
Secondly, if you try to arm responder with some variation on a forcing pass it won’t work -
Best is simply to give partner some useful item of information to help him choose what happens next.
Method 1
On the improvers’ page I suggested:-
bid any five-
redouble with a minimum opener (twelve or an excellent thirteen);
and pass with fourteen or a poor thirteen.
Method 2
On an earlier version of the improvers’ page I reversed the allocation, giving:-
bid any five-
pass with a minimum opener (twelve or an excellent thirteen);
and redouble with fourteen or a poor thirteen.
In either case you might agree either to ignore the five-
My choice is to bid the suit whenever I hold it.
Evaluation
Method 2
is the one which I previously recommended on the improvers’ page.
Redoubling with the stronger holding is the more intuitive method -
It works perfectly well.
Its only drawbacks are that it deprives partner of the option of leaving the doubled but not redoubled contract in facing the stronger holding, and it also deprives responder of the opportunity to use the redouble in some other way (‘I have a five-
Method 1
I recently came across an unattributed handout which I must have received many years ago, and featuring this method, at the bottom of a pile of papers.
The pros and cons are of course the same of those listed above for method two except that they now apply to the weaker holdings.
I must admit that I have a slight preference for method 2.
It seems to me that partner will be more likely to want to leave the redouble in facing the stronger holding, and he will be more likely to want to use the redouble to show a five-
But I must admit that the above thoughts are based on very little practical experience.
I have chosen to offer method 1 first in the improvers’ section as it has at least a hint of pedigree.
| Opener |
| Overcaller |
| Responder |
| Advancer |
| Opener's rebid |
| Overcaller's rebid and beyond |
| Responder's rebid and beyond |
| The continuing auction |