Conventions

Home

M J Bridge

♦

♠

♥

♣

Bidding

Hands

Theory

Context  -  Acol bidding - combining the two-level bids.

Two strong bids


Usually such a system will consist of two artificial, strong and forcing opening bids - almost certainly 2♣ and 2♦ - along with two weak bids in the majors.

On the present page I shall consider only combinations in which an opening 2NT is strong and balanced on a range of twenty to twenty two points.  For alternative options follow this link.


If you allocate 2♦ as artificial and game-forcing, and 2♣ as a strong but limited one-round force along with single-suited weak twos in the majors then you are playing a version of Benjaminised Acol (Benji).


Benjaminised Acol


One version of this system has already been considered under standard methods.


In this version


2♦ was played as game-forcing

2♣ was played as a limited one-round force

2♥ and 2♠ were played as single-suited weak twos on a defined range of five to nine (say)

2NT was played as strong and balanced on a range of twenty to twenty two.


Variations within Benji


This basic implementation is more often than not varied in some detail by partnership agreement.


2♦ is played by many club partnerships as promising twenty three or more points.

I prefer to include strong hands (say 16+) with a lower point-count which are worth 9½ or more playing tricks - i.e. game in their own hand.


2♣ can be played as an unlimited one-round force.

i.e. it might include hands which will force to game on the next bid.

With this choice it will be possible to include the traditional ‘quick trick’ requirement in the 2♦ opening.


2♥ and 2♠ can be varied in all sorts of ways.  Follow the link to single-suited weak twos.


Balanced ranges


The exact range for your opening bid of 2NT is also a matter for partnership choice.


Each of ‘19-20’, ‘20-21’ and ‘21-22’ has its following.


The modified range may have to be accompanied by a revised way of showing other lower ranges.

There is a fuller discussion on the page ‘opening a strong 2NT’.


In general 2♣ followed by 2NT will show the next two-point range (e.g. 23,24)

and 2♦ followed by 2NT will cover stronger hands (e.g.23+).


One not uncommon variation, possibly the original (I don’t know) and certainly still to be found in print, is that 2NT shows the traditional 20 to 22, and the 2♣ opening followed by a 2NT rebid promises just eighteen or nineteen points.

The thought of having to double on just eighteen points to show this hand over intervention scares me somewhat - such an allocation would not be my choice, nor that of very many experts.

If you meet this method then take the opportunity to interfere whenever it is safe to do so.


Having a third way to show a balanced hand is a marked improvement on older methods allowing you to use two-point no trump ranges as above, but you might prefer to use one of these routes for some other purpose such as strong three-suited.


Reverse Benji


The meanings of the 2♣ and 2♦ bids are frequently interchanged, so that 2♣ becomes the game forcing bid as in traditional Acol, and 2♦ the limited one-round force.

This is ‘Reverse Benji’.


This modification satisfies the theoretical requirement that when there are two or more artificial routes to a given point then the ‘cheaper’ route should incorporate the stronger holding, thereby making enemy intervention more dangerous.

Most exponents of this method will probably give the alternative reason that the lower starting point for the powerhouse hands creates more bidding space in which to investigate the best slam.


Reverse Benji is probably theoretically better than Benji, but for most of us the difference will be minimal.

It seems to me that there is little to choose between Benji and reverse Benji.


Benji, in any of its variations, is not a favourite of mine.

You may need to learn a version of this method so that you can partner others at the club, but it is not one of my recommended methods.


The underlying problem is that the powerhouse bid just doesn’t happen often enough, and if you include the ‘quick trick requirement’ it happens even less.  There are better ways to use this bidding space - see below.

Not recommended

Not standard

Non-Benji options


The following basically gives me the opportunity to harp on about two of my hobby horses.

The thoughts included here may be original - they are certainly not standard - and you won’t come to any great harm if you ignore them completely.


If they interest you then you should probably think of them as possible considerations as you come to put your own system together, rather than as a ‘must-play’ blueprint.


These two hobby horse thoughts are:


that in most forms of the game the game-forcing opening bid does not occur sufficiently to justify inclusion,

and that the weak opening bid of 2♥, be it single-suited or two-suited, has only a very limited preemptive effect.


One- or two-suited


If you are keen to maintain the ‘two strong and two weak’ approach then I shall make the idiosyncratic suggestion that rather than use two strong bids to distinguish between strong and very strong you might do better to use them to distinguish between one-suited and two-suited.


In such a system:-


2♣ is a strong one-round force promising eight or more playing tricks in a two-suited hand;

2♦ is a strong one-round force promising eight and a half or more playing tricks in a single-suited hand or a defined range in a balanced hand;

2♥ is natural and weak;

2♠ is natural and weak.


You will be all but alone (although I do play something along these lines with a long-standing partner) but such a system is not totally without merit.


Alternative uses for 2♥


As I mention at every opportunity, consider replacing the weak 2♥ with either a 2♥ assumed fit or a Flannery meaning,


and if you wish to step even further into the unorthodox try interchanging the 2♦ and 2♥ in any of the allocations above.

It is a long way from standard teaching, but I still believe that 2♦ is more preemptive than 2♥.

This page last revised 12th Mar 2018

Beginner and above

Evaluation


Benji is an improvement on traditional Acol in that it incorporates both the highly preemptive weak 2♠ opening bid, and a way of showing the single-suited hand based on a long club suit.


However, the game-forcing opening bid of 2♦ is (in my opinion) wasteful of space - certainly at pairs scoring.  With a minimum requirement of 25 points in a balanced hand in most allocations it will be an even rarer performer than an Acol 2♣!


Also the weak 2♥ opening bid is not nearly as effective as many of its exponents appear to believe, but this is a common defect to be found in many of the alternative systems on offer.


As a starting system, there is much to be said for adopting

‘three weak and one strong’.


Alternatively

adopt the common tournament method of

‘one strong and a multi’.