♦

♠

♥

♣

M J Bridge

Bidding

Home

Hands

Conventions

Theory


♠

♥

♦

♣

N

J 3

8 5 3 2

K 9 5

J 9 3 2


♠

♥

♦

♣

S

K 6 5 2

T 4

Q 8

A K 8 7 5


♠

♥

♦

♣

W

A T 9 8 4

J 7

J T 6

Q T 6


♠

♥

♦

♣

E

Q 7

A K Q 9 6

A 7 4 3 2

4

Hand

BBO 27.01.21 Hand 8



Dealer

West

Vulnerability

None

W

N

E

S

-

-

1♥

-

1NT

-

2♦

-

2♠

-

-

-

Context - Acol bidding - hands - post mortems.

Previous hand


Two bidding sequences follow.


The first is what actually happened at the table.


Sequence 1


The initial 1NT response denies four spades.

The 1NT response should only ever be used when the hand is too good to pass and no better alternative available.  In bypassing the spade suit a spade fit will never be found if opener holds five hearts and four spades in a weak hand (even if you don’t play strong reverses you don’t want to force to the three-level on what might be 15 points facing 6 in a misfit) - or four hearts, four spades, and fifteen points.

On responder’s rebid opener has shown at least five hearts and four diamonds.  There is no good reason to think that there might be a better fit in spades than the known 5-2 fit in hearts.  Even if 2♠ existed as a real possibility at this point it should promise at least a six-card suit.


Sequence 2


Opener starts with the higher-ranking of two five-card suits, responder shows their spade suit at the one-level, and opener rebids in diamonds promising at least 5-4 shape and up to about 18 points.


Responder then bids 2♥.

This might appear to be a false preference, but 5-2 tends to play better than 4-3 and, it keeps the bidding open for opener to bid again with 17 or 18.


As above 2♠ would promise a six-card suit.


If opener values his hand as better than 15 points then he might bid again with 3♦ after which West with eight points will choose their game contract - any one of 3NT, 4♥ or 5♦ and none of them very comfortable.


What happens?


Diamonds made 9 tricks twice and 11 tricks once.

It should lose at least 1 club, 1 diamond and 1 spade so the game contract is not good.


3NT was played once making eight tricks.

As long as the defence find clubs fairly early (which they should on the bidding) there is no hope for 9 tricks.


Hearts made 10 tricks 3 times and 9 tricks 4 times.

If the defence gets it right they will take 2 diamonds, 1 club and 1 spade.


Spades made 9, 10 and 11 tricks once each and 8 tricks twice.


In principle the 5-2 fit in spades is as good as the 5-2 fit in hearts.  In practice, provided the defence take their tricks in the side suits before they get away on the hearts, then the spade losers mean that declarer will always be in difficulty.


Although 4♥ scores well (+6.7 imps) if you get away with it the correct contract is 2♥ + 1 scoring a mere +0.1


And the second shows a more standard sequence on the hand.

W

N

E

S

-

-

1♥

-

1♠

-

2♦

-

2♥

-

-

-