Once again the bidding is what happened as opposed to what should have happened.
Some might open a weak 2♦ on the North hand, but a combination of point-count, suit quality, vulnerability, and position at the table suggest otherwise. Not vulnerable in third seat it would be far more attractive.
1♣ by East is routine.
I hate the double by South - nowhere to go if North responds in hearts.
I was West - see below.
W
N
E
S
-
1♣
x
xx
1♦
2♣
2♦
2♥
-
3♣
-
Context - Acol bidding - hands - post mortems.
The redouble
A simple forcing change of suit would certainly be routine (and quite possibly best), but with holdings in both majors (implied by South) and a poor fit for partner this seemed like a good opportunity to pave the way for a subsequent penalty double - anyway, I wanted to give the redouble a run out.
Redouble at this point in the auction is always played as showing a good non-fit hand. Nine points is the old standard minimum - insist on 10 if partner’s opening style tends towards the skimpy.
North rightly looked for a safe escape, East correctly showed the nature of the hand, South should probably have remained silent although 2♦ is not unreasonable.
I was now able to show my suit, and perhaps the auction should have ended here, but East went again, possibly under the impression that I held club support.
What happened?
EW played the cards at all 16 tables.
3NT made 9 once and 8 three times;
Hearts made 12, 10, 9, 9, 9, 8, 8;
Clubs made 10,9,9,8,8.
With most contracts going 1 off, 3♣ making scored well for us (+2.5 imps), but hearts making 9 would have scored better with +3.3.
There are easier ways to bid the EW cards, but an instructive deal none-the-less.